I love love love this eyeliner !! Not only is the colour so very vivid but it makes doing a wing sooooo easy !! I also live the fact that this liner lasts me all day when I'm sweating at work . I highly recommend this product for anyone who loves having perfect eyeliner wings :)

I like how this product applies and I find that it lasts much longer than other liquid eyeliners. I would buy this product again and again.

You will get a gorgeous line with this beautiful fine brush. Long lasting with no smudging, and very easy to remove.

This is my current go to daily eyeliner. It isn't good enough to be holy grail status, but good enough that I haven't touched another liner in months. I would definitely NEVER purchase it for full price, but have been lucky enough to get some good package deals that included an All Day liner in them that I now have two in rotation.

I keep one in my gym bag (I'm there at 5:45 am three days each week), and I have gotten several comments from other ladies admiring how I can whip out a cat eye in less than a minute. A lot of this is technique and not necessarily the liner, but I do find that this Stila liner makes the process a lot easier. The pointed felt tip maintains moisture and hasn't dried out yet, and the point hasn't frayed.

The liner itself is a deep black, goes on opaque and not streaky, and lasts all day if I can keep myself from rubbing my eyes. I like that the liner doesn't go on glossy (some liquid liners dry with a sheen), and that I can achieve a super fine or thick line depending on application technique.

The cons? Price. That would be about it. If I find other package deals I'll repurchase, otherwise I'll go back to my tried and true Physicians Formula liquid liner pen for less than half the price.

Best liquid eyeliner!
Does what it says, stays all day and stays BLACK (not grey like others)
My fave eyeliner and one I can't do without! Thankfully it's back in the uk

One of my favourite go to liquid liners. It really does stay on all day, won't budge. It only comes off when you want it to. The color payoff it's super great. Try it out. I love it so much I had to get other colors. Moss is a great forest green one. It's a nice change from black if you don't want to be too adventurous. I very much recommend this product.

I love how this eye liner applies, but not how long the pen itself lasts.

When I first bought it the tip was great, application was smooth and the color is VERY long lasting. However, as time goes by, the end of the felt tip starts to thicken and lines get messier. It's also very necessary to store the liner upside-down in order for the remaining liquid to properly fill the felt tip. Trimming the felt flyaways help prolong the life of this pen.

So while I still love the effectiveness and quality of the liner, I also dislike how soon application loses its precision. Cat eye styles are nearly impossible after a short time, so for that I definitely recommend a pot/brush liner combo.

A little pricey, but it is AMAZING! I have oily skin and this will stay on forever. NEVER smudges or slides. You can control how thick you want the line and the color is very rich and opaque.

This eyeliner is easy to use. It's precise. It goes on dark. Great staying power. Love it!

I remember going into Sephora and asking about the best liquid eye liners; Stila's liquid eye liner was mentioned. It is waterproof and stays on all day. It is easy to apply onto your eyes, and doesn't smudge. I have not had a problem with this liquid eye liner. All my girlfriends who ask which liquid eye liner I use, also agrees that Stila makes one of the best ones. At around $19 for the one I bought at Sephora, it was worth it! (And the amount itself is quite a bit, so it will last awhile!).