Worst thing ever!

Hate this product. Streaky, does not apply smoothly, jumps on the line and needs multiple coats in order to reach full opacity. It dries quick and is clay-based, so when you try to build up the color it flakes and balls and smudges. Makes a mess under your eye and since it is waterproof, it's a mess to fix the fall out.

Even if you do get a nice line first go, it flakes under the eye within a minute or two. And despite being "waterproof", it is very sensitive to oil, so if you have oily lids prepare for it to get smudged within 30 minutes. Very very disappointing. Would not recommend!

Love these as shadows and liners

I LOVE this. I use it on my eyelid as a shadow, but I set it with a powder over top. It is so pigmented, does not crease, and feels very comfortable. It dries down fairly quickly and lasts the entire day. I definitely want more colours. Highly recommend.