I love how these eyeliner pencils go on so smooth. Vibrant colours. My only issue with these is the price is a little high so I only buy basic colours and save the 'fun' colours for when I am buying less expensive dupes, like NYX Slide On eyeliners.

Best eyeliner ever! You pay for what you get. It is pricey but I won't be able to go back to drugstore brand any time soon. Lasts a good 3-4 hours on the WATERLINE and 8-10 on the eyelid. Glides easily without tugging at the delicate eye area!

I don't particularly favor pencil eyeliners because they are hard but this one wasn't that bad. It glided on easily, didn't smudge as easy as some others I have tried (but wasn't really water proof!), and was affordable. Now, after sharpening it wasn't great to use, it was a little hard and the wood chips weren't in tact very well.

Best gel pencil ever!!! Its a definite must have.

I love this eyeliner. I am always trying eyeliner out because I never love it but this one goes on easily, stays put and really made a difference in my look. I bought the Oil Slick color which is a dark grey with silver meatllic flecks. I love the unexpected metallic look in a daytime make-up- and it also works at night. Softer than the harsher blacks I was used too - I am sold on this eyeliner. Easy to sharpen, comes with a cap.

This product applies effortlessly and it is so pigmented. The black is jet black and it always maintains a nice creamy texture for a pencil so there is no tugging. I love using it. The only problem is that it smudges a little when I use it on my upper lid after extended periods of time, which is still better than most eyeliners (I do have slightly oily eyelids too) so because of this I typically use it when I am lining my bottom lash line and it does a fabulous job

I just started using this eyeliner last week but I'm already in love! It glides on smoothly and lasts all day. I'm off to buy more colours!!

OKAY, so I am South Asian, so eyeliner for us is a key beauty essential! I have tried every eyeliner in the book (Makeup Forver Aqua Eyes, Mac, Stila etc.) THIS IS BY FAR THE BEST PENCIL EYELINER (to wear under the waterline).

All eyeliners, no mater what they advertise smudge. However, I have to admit, this eyeliner hardly smudges. It is bold dark and always moist which I really like. It does not dry out like my other ones. I wear it everyday it lasted me about 4-5 months. TRUST ME. Go to Sephora try it out, the great thing about Sephora is that if you dont like it you can bring it back.

These are my favorite eyeliners in the world. I have a few of them, black, silver, purple, and white. They are creamy and smooth making them easy to apply. They may not stay on for a complete 24 hours but close enough for me!

These Eye Pencils are just amazing! The colors are beautiful and the eye liner is mistake proof. It glides on so easily that anyone could use it. My favorite eye liner ever.