We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eye Liner - Prestige Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
1-20 of 187

Kat Von D Tattoo Liner

311 reviews

I liked this liquid eyeliner, it’s dark and waterproof. I love the felt tip, it makes it very easy to apply. I did find that the product wouldn’t come out as well when I first opened it, so I had to wet it on my tongue. This liner did last me a long while though.
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

208 reviews

This is the only liquid eyeliner I've used for years because it's easy to use and it really does stay on all day for me, despite my oily lids. I like the felt tip, although I find that sometimes it sheds a little at the tip and I have to remove the shedding parts before I...
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil

169 reviews

I really liked these eyeliner pencils, especially espresso. They have great formulations and staying power. The only draw back I have found is that they don't fit into standard eyeliner sharpeners. But other than that they are awesome and I would definitely repurchase them.
Stila all day waterproof liquid eyeliner

44 reviews

This is my absolute favourite liquid eyeliner. I wear it everyday. Glides on smoothly and creates the perfect cat eye. This one of the best product out there and by far the best one that I have been using for 9 years. I always purchase their Christmas package because you get a...
Kat Von D Ink Liner

48 reviews

I bought this after being recommended it by a Sephora employee. I wanted an eyeliner that made it easy to create sharp cat-eye looks, and this product certainly does the job. Unlike KVD's Tattoo liner, this one has a felt tip that delivers full opacity in one swipe. I don't like...
Kat Von D Tattoo Liquid Eyeliner

17 reviews

I love this eyeliner so much! I have bought it a few times and it works so well. It goes on smooth and dries fast so it does not smudge and stays on until you take it off! It also lasts a long time. I have bought 2 in like a year. I don't use it every single day, but I do use it...
Benefit Cosmetics They're Real! Push Up Liner

101 reviews

I bought the beyond green shade from Sephora awhile back. I was really excited to try it because I thought it had a marker-tip applicator. Unfortunately, it doesn't. It is a gel liner that comes through a slit in the end. It's not easy to apply. It does stay on through sweat and...
Marc Jacobs Highliner Gel Eye Crayon Eyeliner

22 reviews

I love the quality of this eyeliner! It goes on soo smoothly and sharp. I also really enjoy the feature you can twist for more eyeliner instead of sharpening it with a sharpener. This was a Sephora recommendation, which I love...but it also runs throughout time, just like all...
Stila eyeliner micro tip

6 reviews

I used to use the other stila liquid eyeliner but now I use this one and it is my fav!! it has a super thin tip which makes it super easy if you just want a thin line or if you’re not very good at eyeliner like me. It lasts all day and there is so much product that it lasts...
Urban Decay Psycadellic Sister Eyeliner

1 review

The purple is very vibrant and does last 24 hours if not longer. Goes on very smooth and pigmented. No need to go over your lines one swipe and your done! Does not bleed down your eyes during the day as you heat up/ sweat!
inglot acm eyeliner gel 78

1 review

I love this gel eyeliner! It is one of my favorites, it is very black and easy to apply, it goes on smoothly. It lasts all day long and perfect for a dramatic eye look or night out.
tarte tarteist double take eyeliner

1 review

I love this eyeliner. It is perfect for traveling, you get a liquid eyeliner and a crayon liner in one. It is so easy to apply and goes on smoothly and the color is very black.
Clinique Pretty Easy Liquid Eyelining Pen

15 reviews

Love Clinique's Pretty Easy Liquid Eyelining Pen. It's easy to use and apply. The liner liquid stays on my lids for more than 24 hours and doesn't smudge! Light feel and I had no reactions to it (I have sensitive skin).
Vasanti Cleopatra Black Liquid Eyeliner

2 reviews

This liner is really great and the only thing I’d say is under quality is the packaging. My Lid separated from the brush but it’s still super manageable. The liner itself is great, goes on smooth and dries very fast as a Matte black. The applicator is super easy to use as...
Marc Jacobs Beauty Highliner Matte Gel Eye Crayon

6 reviews

I love this eyeliner goes on smooth..lasts forever .don't get it wet though ..it doesn't work properly if it's wet. ..bit pricey..but worth it. Has a sharpener on the end.
Ciate London Fierce Flicks Eyeliner

10 reviews

The Ciate London Fierce Flicks Precision Tip Liquid Liner Black is great! Very easy to apply and lasts all day. The pen is thin and applies well so thin lines are easy to draw with no smearing or smudging. I tried the star stamp and it worked great! Great product!
Makeup Forever Aqua EyeLiner

9 reviews

This eyeliner is just great it’s long lasting and waterproof plus doesn’t smudge at all and has a nice liquid Texture just love it u should try it once
MAC Skiny Eyeliner

1 review

MAC Skiny eyeliner, COOL Black, Lasting blooming. I am totally satisfied, I've never been that professional on drawing eyeliner but when I used this product I got cat eyes. It stays long and super smooth and precise eyelines. It was not irritating my eyes. I was confortable...
Saphora Marc Jacobs Undersmoke Kit

1 review

This adorable little trio of award winning, gel eyeliner and volumizing mascara is a must have! Glides well, clean lines and stays for hours and hours. Just used it with the Cream & Sugar Nude Lip, looks fantastic! Check it out at Saphora!
Jonteblu Eyeliner Pencil

1 review

I received the Jonteblue Glittering Star Eyeliner in my monthly BoxyCharm subscription box and I wasn't over thrilled with this eyeliner. I found that the pencil was harder than other eyeliners I have been using for many years now. I wasn't overly impressed with having to...