We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eye Liner - Prestige Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
21-40 of 191

MAC Skiny Eyeliner

1 review

MAC Skiny eyeliner, COOL Black, Lasting blooming. I am totally satisfied, I've never been that professional on drawing eyeliner but when I used this product I got cat eyes. It stays long and super smooth and precise eyelines. It was not irritating my eyes. I was confortable...
Saphora Marc Jacobs Undersmoke Kit

1 review

This adorable little trio of award winning, gel eyeliner and volumizing mascara is a must have! Glides well, clean lines and stays for hours and hours. Just used it with the Cream & Sugar Nude Lip, looks fantastic! Check it out at Saphora!
Jonteblu Eyeliner Pencil

1 review

I received the Jonteblue Glittering Star Eyeliner in my monthly BoxyCharm subscription box and I wasn't over thrilled with this eyeliner. I found that the pencil was harder than other eyeliners I have been using for many years now. I wasn't overly impressed with having to...
Lancome Artliner - Precision Point Eyeliner

8 reviews

I have been using this product daily for over 15 years. My skin is very oily even on my eyelids and every other eyeliner I tried didn't stay. Artliner doesn't smudge throughout the day, and the precise tip brush is great for application. It's very expensive but worth it for...
Estee Lauder The Blackest Liner

1 review

This is a great product from a great brand! Also very reasonably priced! This would last me a month, using it once a day. One swipe and your done. The best eyeliner I have ever had!
It - Waterproof Anti-Aging Gel Eyeliner

1 review

The shade I had was Silk Taupe and it really is a gorgeous shade. Softens eyes beautifully and there is quite a selection of shades to choose from. I found it transferred easily onto my hooded lids and was quite a soft product. I began storing it in the fridge after it broke...
Shiseido Inkstroke Gel Eyeliner

2 reviews

This is probably the one thing I would choose to have if I was only allowed one beauty product for the rest of my life. The pigment is UNREAL! The blackest black I’ve ever experienced, and the formula is so so smooth! A little goes a long way, and it is such an easy product to...
kat von d eye liner

2 reviews

This is the absolute best eyeliner I have EVER used. if you want cat eyes THIS is the liner you need. goes on so smooth and lasts all day long. would be purchasing again for sure!
Urban decay 24/7 waterline eyeliner

9 reviews

so it was already broken when i got it, then when i tried to sharpen it just kept snapping off over & over. i called the store & they said since it was used they couldn't exchange it...even tho i hadn't actually used it. it was like $30 too so super disappointed all around with...
tarte Tarteist Clay Paint Liner

6 reviews

Packaging exploded and made a huge mess on my white vanity. I know many others have had this problem. The product itself is good. The liner is easy to apply, smooth, super pigmented and lasts forever.
Lancôme paris Grandiôse Liner

5 reviews

I purchased 5 of these Black, 04,06,07,08 These are really nice liners, they glide really smooth (though the brush doesn't take on a lot of colour) have to a apply a few coats, must shake product a few times to get better colour, dry pretty fast, the bendable wand is pretty...
Nude by Nature Contour Eye Pencil

1 review

I usually use liquid eye liner but i received this as a #freeproduct and i can say that i do not mind this pencil. I like how easy it goes on, how thin the line is and the fact that it is smooth application and doesn't pull on my eyelid! I really enjoyed playing with the...
Urban decay perversion eye pen

2 reviews

I love the application of this product and the fact that it lasts and lasts for over 12 hours!! I think it's about $30 on average which is more than I would like to spend on eyeliner but I can't find anything that beats the application
Tarte clay pot liner

2 reviews

I use this product in Cobalt for my blue eyebrows! The clay pot applies flawlessly and with a little primer over my brows I am able to get awesome arched brows that last all day without smudge or melting.
r Urban Decay Razor Sharp Water-Resistant Longwear Liquid Eyeliner

4 reviews

I am a very picky buyer when it comes to my eyeliner and I have tried so many around the market this literally is affordable high quality in standards and amazing in every way it definitely checked all my boxes I love it
Marc jacobs eyeliner

9 reviews

I have the Marx Jacobs eyeliner in black. It goes on so smoothly and stays on all day and night! I absolutely love this product and it is true black without a tinge of green or blue like most!! Would highly reccamend. Worth the money
Butter London Glazen Lustrous Liner

1 review

There is nothing to rave about. It has a weird texture, I can rub it off super easily. The applicator and is nice and precise. The formula isn't great, it has a weird metallic sheen that makes my eyeliner appear wet, which isn't my deal.
Smashbox Always Sharp 3D Liner

1 review

I'm obsessed with gold eyeliner as a blonde with blue eyes and 3D Cleopatra is by far my favorite one. It is always easy to apply and always sharp just like it says. Plus you don't have to sharpen it! The other colors I own in these pencils are equally fantastic and rich in...
Makeup forever gel eyeliner

1 review

This is THE BEST waterproof gel eyeliner I have come across! I was having so many issues with finding the perfect waterproof gel eyeliner that does not smudge until the Sephora rep recommended me this product! It does not smudge over my eyelids like the other gel eyeliner! It...
Smashbox Always Sharp Waterproof Kohl Liner

16 reviews

This eyeliner is absolutely worth the price. It generally sells for about $25 a piece but I assure you is is worth every dollar! This eyeliner does not smudge or smear and lasts for a long time without worry of having to retouch or reapply. It is waterproof but do not fret! this...