We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eye Liner - Prestige Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
101-120 of 191

Make Up For Ever Artist Liner

6 reviews

I got this in a gift set from Sephora. I have been trying to find a great blackest black eyeliner to stay in my waterline without ending up looking like a raccoon. This was just okay for me. I found that I still had to set it with black eyeshadow. I probably wouldn't repurchase...
Sephora Long Lasting Eyeliner in Metallic Gold

1 review

Very true to it's color, and very long lasting. I bought it on a whim for a black and gold themed party and it lasted all night and got quiet a few compliments about it. Love the other colors in the collection as well.
Make Up For Ever Ink Liner

3 reviews

Très bon produit, facile a utiliser (et je suis débutante). La couleur est vraiment bien noire et la texture est parfaite. Je recommande ce produit sans problèmes.
Sephora Contour Eye Pencil

8 reviews

I recently purchased this liner and I love it! It stays put really well and I love the color selection. I have #12 Cappuccino glitter and I will be adding to my collection and throwing out my old liners (there is probably 25 to throw out!). Thankyou to Sephora for this...
Make Up For Ever Aqua Liner in Diamond White

1 review

Long lasting, water and smudge proof liquid liner. I love how sparkly it actually is. I wear a thin line under my bottom lash line before applying mascara for that extra something something in an everyday look.
STILA Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner in Purple Tang

3 reviews

I'm actually surprised this product didn't get more (positive) reviews! This is one of the only eyeliners that stay where I apply it and won't creep into the corners of my eyes or underneath my eyes! Awesome eyeliner! So happy I've found this!
Sephora Collection Colourful Waterproof Eyeliner 24 HR wear

2 reviews

Still going to be looking for a great waterproof eyeliner. for the price and everyday wear it is great. I am afraid that it doesn't last as long as I would like.
Lancôme Paris Long Wear Gel Eyeliner

3 reviews

Expensive but high quality. Make sure you wet the brush first for a cleaner line
Sephora Long Lasting Eyeliner High Precision Brush

5 reviews

This eyeliner is perfect. It's well pigmented, lasts all day, washes away fairly easily, and the brush is delicate and easy to handle. The price is great considering that I use it daily and only use 3-4 bottles a year. The bottles are small, but the brush barely needs to be...
Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyeliner

1 review

#13 Matte Balck. It was a little bit runny for my liking, but it wasn't a super bold black, it was a more subtle blended looking black. Would buy it again
Urban Decay Waterproof Cream Pot Eye Liner

3 reviews

I always use liquid liners, not gel liners so I didn't really like this as much.
Sephora Colorful Eyeliner 24HR Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner in Black Lace

7 reviews

Love this liner. It lasts all day, goes on easy and is perfect for subtle or bold occasions. I find it really easy to use and I love the thin sponge tip rather than a brush. I also love that it doesn’t flake or crumble off. I wouldn’t say it’s waterproof but unless you...
Sephora Collection Cushion Glossy Eyeliner

1 review

This is by far the worst eyeliner that I have ever used! It came very highly recommended by the staff at Sephora because it is a new product bundle (the bundle is the eyeliner, as well as a Sephora eyeliner brush). The product is just terrible. I would consider myself a...
Sephora Waterproof Eye Liner Pencil

3 reviews

I've tried many many different liners. Some say they are waterproof but they aren't. This stuff is unbelievable!! I have a bunch of colours now and probably won't use anything else.
Bobbi Brown Long Wear Eye Pencil

1 review

I redeemed a Bobbi Brown gift box with my points at Sephora and a travel size of this eyeliner was in there. If you are a person who likes black eyeliner, this eyeliner is BLACK. It is so dark, I don't know if it is possible to make it any darker and that is what makes this...
Kat Von D Waterproof Autograph Pencil

1 review

This liner lasts the entire day! No smudging, no raccoon eyes. Love it.
Shiseido Integrate Black Liquid Eyeliner

1 review

Shiseido Integrate Black liquid eyeliner. PRO: I LOVE this liquid eyeliner, it's easy to put on, unless you smudge it, it usually stays on all day....and best of all, it's cheap, about $15 cdn (can't remember what that translates to in Japanese yen). Cons: It's only sold in...
Tarte Skinny Smolder Eyes

1 review

I have this in onyx, which is a nice, deep black. It smudges and blends really nicely. However, my eyelids sometimes get oily during the day, and this eyeliner will smudge right off.
Benefit pushup eyeliner

5 reviews

If you're looking for precision, this not the liner for you...if your toddlers need new crayons--hey you can repurpose your $$ purchase! I tried this and hated it instantly, it feels like goop/crayon and the brush is completely useless as it doesn't allow for a straight line...
tarte Amazonian Clay Waterproof Liner (with Double-ended Brush)

4 reviews

I absolutely love tarte products and this liner stays on all day long for me.