Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
41-60 of 1417

CoverGirl trunaked Roses Eyeshadow Palette

18 reviews

Totally disappointing and waste of money! I bout this because the colours made for a beautiful palette. Unfortunately they were all chalky and there was a lot of fall age on the face. The pigment was next to nil and it didn't stick to the eye lid.
Tarte Grav3yardgirl Swamp Queen Palette

16 reviews

I love Bunny and Tarte products, so I was sure that I would love this palette, unfortunately that is not the case. I do love the effort that Bunny put into designing this palette, and the colours she chose for it. I also love the gorgeous packaging, It is very sturdy and lovely...
e.l.f. Cosmetics Mad for Matte Eyeshadow Palette

9 reviews

This eyeshadow palette is totally worth it! First of all, it's very affordable, one of the greatest things about ELF. I hadn't used it lately and today i saw it in my makeup bin and decided to use it. My eyes turned out good. The only problem I have is there doesn't seem to be...
Pür Cosmetics Soirèe Diaries

4 reviews

love this palette. not a boxycharm subscriber but actually bought it from someone who got it in their box. the size was a bit disappointing in person (it just looked bigger in pictures) but I love the colours - especially the shimmer ones
Morphe Jaclyn Hill Palette

3 reviews

If I needed just one palette for the rest of my life, this would be it! It has every colour you need! The colours are so buttery and pigmented. They blend like a dream! I use this palette pretty much everyday. It's so affordable as well!! Everyone needs to run and buy this...
Too faced peach pallet

5 reviews

I can't get enough of this pallet! I love the shades, they really make my eyes pop big time. The scent is very nice and mellow too. I just wish they included a applicator brush with it!
Younique Mineral Eye Pigments

25 reviews

These mineral powders when used dry are very translucent. However, if you wet your brush and put powder into the lid they make for long lasting eye colour. I love the variety of shimmer and matte colours. I just dont like using them dry.
ColourPop Super Shock Eye Shadow Collection

3 reviews

These are the only single eyeshadow pots I will buy now since I usually just go with pallets,they're wonderful long lasting quality, various vibrant colors and great price!
Anastasia Beverly hills - Subculture Palette

6 reviews

WOW WOW WOW! I got this palette because I’d heard so many great things about it! I have to say I was not disappointed! The colours are amazing and super creamy and pigmented. I had to be careful with how much my brush picked up because the colours are intense! I’ll be buying...
Tarte make believe in yourself eye and cheek pallet

3 reviews

I love this palette! I ordered it online. The colors are beautiful and shimmery, to me, some are almost duo chrome! They seem to all have a hint of pink undertone that make it appear different from what is in the pans. However, due to this the colors blend perfectly. I see many...
Huda Beauty Rose Gold Palette

16 reviews

I was curious about the textured eye shadows in this palette so I decided to buy it. I thought the shadows blend beautifully and are pigmented. The textured colours are so neat! They give the eye a cool look. I want to get the dessert dusk palette just because I liked this one...
Soiree Diaries Eyeshadow Palette By Pur The Complexion Authority

3 reviews

Another eyeshadow palette from Boxycharm which I most definitely am not complaining about. I love eyeshadow palettes, even ones I don't use very much are still very welcome. This palette is called an essential palette. As it is full of neutrals and earthy shades I have to...
Urban Decay Jean-Michel Basquiat Gold Griot Eyeshadow Palette

3 reviews

This palette is buttery, pigmented, blendable, and just amazing. I love the concept of using some of his art as the packaging, and I just love the colours.
Maybelline The City Mini Palette x Shayla

2 reviews

This product feels like a high end product! Love the warm colours and there is not much fallout so its amazing quality for a good price. I also love the packaging and will buy thos product again especially for parties where I need to dress up!
Maybelline New York The Rock Nudes™ Eye Shadow Palette

6 reviews

This is one of my cult classics (I can't believe I forgot to review this beauty, I am on my 2nd palette) The color combinations all blend perfectly together and really speak to my personality, light but dark, cool but hot, quiet but loud and safe but risky! Plus I was instantly...
Stila Eyeshadow - Kitten

15 reviews

The colour on this shadow is a very beautiful shimmer, BUT, it gets everywhere!! I also find that it transfers really easily.....from my eyelid to the brow bone area. I'm a little disappointed because it looks beautiful but it is extremely flaky.
ELF Studio Baked Eyeshadow Trio

5 reviews

elf has beautiful shades that are great quality. luckily they are both cheap and long lasting. in my opinion, they either match or exceed a lot of the high end brands for a small fraction of the price. if you are looking for beautiful neutrals, give elf a shot
Naked 3 eyeshadow palette

4 reviews

You can not go wrong with Urban Decay, there naked eye shadow palette says it all! I love the pigments and the colors are off the charts. It is on the pricey side but worth every penny!
Tarteist pro palette

6 reviews

This is my favourite palette I own, colours are beautiful and the pigmentation is perfect! Tarte never fails me! The shadows last me all day and sometimes night when I head out. I honestly can't say nothing negative its probably one of the best palettes out there.
Mac Cosmetics Pro Pigment Powder Eye Shadow

40 reviews

J'ai beaucoup aimer ces pigment de chez Mac. Il est important de mouiller son pinceau avant d'appliquer les pigments aussi non cela ne tiens pas. Je les trouve un peu cher, mais cela vaut totalement le prix. Le produit peut vous durer très longtemps. Il vous donne un super look...