Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Find reviews on:
Category:
Sort by:  
DateRating

41-60 of 1260

Stila Eyeshadow - Kitten
The colour on this shadow is a very beautiful shimmer, BUT, it gets everywhere!! I also find that it transfers really easily.....from my eyelid to the brow bone area. I'm a little disappointed because it looks beautiful but it is extremely flaky.


15 reviews
Younique eyeshadow pallet
I absolutely love Youniques Eyeshadow Pallets. I have two of them. As with most Younique products, a little goes a long way. The pigments are rich and go on very smoothly. They are also universal as a eyeliner!


5 reviews
L'Oreal Paris La Couleur Infallible 24HR Eye Shadow
This is a great product. It's definitely one that I will continue to use. I'm very pleased at how well it really did work. I think everyone should try it!


38 reviews
Too Faced Sweet Peach Eye Shadow Collection Palette
These are gorgeous colours that have a fun peach scent. The eyeshadows have little fallout go on nice and smooth and blend amazingly well together. Only wish they included a eye shadow brush in the pallet


9 reviews
Pixi by petra eye shadow palette in plum quartz
I have been wondering about Pixi products. I see them at Shoppers Drug mart. after reading the reviews I think that Im going to try them out. Thanks ladies on the positive reviews I love the color of the palette.


4 reviews
Mac Cosmetics Pro Pigment Powder Eye Shadow
Holy Pigment!! Nothing else compares to these loose powders! Lasts forever (application requires the smallest amount of product), colour goes on true, super easy to blend, and at a very reasonable price for such a premium product. Be careful though! Use a flat stiff brush for...


39 reviews
Tarteist pro palette
My new fav palette! The pigmentation is incredible, the shadows blend beautifully. You can create so many looks! Love the giant mirror and quality of the palette package.


5 reviews
NYX "Butt" Naked Eyes
I enjoy any of these products there is follow it's not very creamy but the pigmentation is good I highly recommend Andy NYX products it's one of my top favorite stores the blush and the bronzer work very well stay on all day Shadows are good also again highly pigmented but just...


4 reviews
Lise Watier 24 HRS GLAM Eyeshadow
This cream eyeshadow is amazing. It' looks like a jumbo pencil. You can use it like a liner, like an eyeshadoe or like an eyeshadow base! Its suuuuuuper long wearing, it will not crease, i promise! :O


2 reviews
Anastasia Beverly Hills Master Palette by Mario
I know this is a limited edition palette but it is definitely my holy grail! The colours are so beautiful and pigmented. You don't need a heavy hand, a little goes a long way with this palette. Every color glides on super easy. The only small issue is there is a lot of fall out...


5 reviews
ELF Studio Baked Eyeshadow Trio
Elf eyeshadow is great it comes in an array of great colors in the three trios and goes on great. The eyeshadows are so reasonably priced you could buy all the combinations and not even feel remotely bad about it.


3 reviews
Naked 2 eyeshadow Pallet
I am head over heels for the Naked 2 palette.the palette has 12 beautiful shades, where it is easy to have a day time look or something more dramatic. This was the palette I used for my wedding to create the perfect gold smokey eye.


3 reviews
Smashbox covershot
I wanted some bright eyeshadows so I got the Smashbox Bold Covershot pallette. It is so much fun creating looks with these colours, they are very pigmented and look amazing.


3 reviews
CoverGirl Eye Shadow Palette
I purchased the Cover Girl Nudes Eyeshadow Palette, and I'm in love!!! It doesn't cake on, it goes on smooth and stays smooth. I love the colours. I have gotten rid of all my other eye shadows, and will have to re-up on the Cover Girl nudes eyeshadow. I have been wearing makeup...


16 reviews
Mary Kay Cream Eye Color
The colors look pretty on, but personally I preferred Mary Kay's pressed powder eye color much more. The cream felt too heavy on my eye and dried out quickly in the container, making it harder and harder to use until I had to throw it away. It looked good, it just wasn't what I...


37 reviews
Annabelle chrome eyeshadow
I've only owned one before, but it was my favourite eye shadow ever. I haven't seen it in stores for awhile, which is why I don't use it anymore. It held up so well without primer! I wore it all day without any issues.


4 reviews
Nyx Prismatic Shadow
I have a few shades but my favorite is the shade frostbite and it's absolutely amazing! I use it an inner corner highlight and a cheek highlight (I'm very pale). These shadows blend easily and have very minimal fallout. These are VERY pigmented! They don't even require a white...


4 reviews
smashbox  EYE SHADOW COVER SHOT EYE PALETTE
This is a nice little palette to travel with and I especially love it in "Golden Hour!" The shade are pigmented and creamy, even the matte ones! It's great for carrying around in your bag! Good price and A+ for convenience!


3 reviews
Urban Decay Afterdark Palette
I love every colour in this pallet and I love how pigmentated they are . However i wish there was some mate eye shadow to make it easy to work just one pallet . I feel like I need to different pallet to make these colour work


2 reviews
NYX Dream Catcher Palette Gold Horizons
My new favorite palette at the moment. I love trying different eye palettes and this one is superb! I have tried NYX eye shadows in the past but this one is the best for me. It goes on beautifully. Is super pigmented and stays on all day ( bonus) . I love the secret mirror...


2 reviews



The Hot List

Trending products on ChickAdvisor curated by our members & advisors.