We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
41-60 of 1610

Mary Kay At Play Baked Eye Trio

31 reviews

I love this brand and the trendy colors of the shadows. They are great for blending and stays in place unlike most shadows. I just love not having to fix my eye shadow when I'm out. Other shadows I've tried tend to make their way into the creases even when using a primer. With...
Peaches and cream Gatsby pigment

1 review

I bought Gatsby pigment from peaches and cream during their Christmas sale. I wore this pigment on my wedding day and felt beautiful. The shared of this pigment is the most classic beautiful gold with a dazzling amount of sparkle. This could be used for the most glamorous Eye...
Carmi x revolution

1 review

The palette is a mixture of shimmers and Matt shades. You can create lots of different looks. It’s also very affordable. I’d repurchase this once I’ve finished my existing.
Tarte rainforest  pallet

1 review

I love the tarte pallets especially when I grab them on sale .the colours are Easy to build great payoff. But they do fall out a little but I find all eyeshadow do ..
The body shop eye color stick

1 review

This color is soft and subtle. I have psoriasis on my eyelids so they are sensitive to eyeshadow. I use this a lot and it doesn't cause a break out. I love sparkle and this has a nice softer day time sparkle to it.
Colorpop smoke show palette

2 reviews

I love this colorpop palette I can make the perfect smokey eye with it! It's amazing and super pigmented it lasts all day! I dont have to reapply and it never smudges for me! I have so many of these palettes 😍
Pür Cosmetics Soirèe Diaries

16 reviews

I like that it’s a natural palette and it colours you could wear everyday.earth colours really make my blue eyes pop.I found though some shades where not as pigmented as others and you had to go over same area few times.But the effect was nice,just had to work few colours...
Huda beauty eyeshadow

2 reviews

HUDA beauty’s got the best eye shadows pallets. I’m totally in love with them. The way they makes my eyes look and glow omg Can’t think of any other eye shadows after you have used this one. Such a good product.
Colourpop 'Yes, Please!' Shadow Palette

7 reviews

This palette is so nice and very versatile you can create many looks with it from super subtle to intense! It is one of my every day essentials in my makeup routine!
Lise Watier Solo eyeshadow Boho Chic

1 review

I’ve been looking for a while now for eyeshadow with just a bit a sparkle. They would always be too sparkly and glittery. I decided to invest a little bit more money and I wasn’t disappointed at all. This is the perfect Creamy like texture and it will stay on all day.
Colourpop Sweet Talk Palette

4 reviews

It has the most stunning colours! It blends easy and like a dream! Perfect for spring. And it is also extremely affordable! I love every look I create with it!
Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eye Shadow

1 review

This eyeshadow stick is my favourite as very easy To apply and gives a sooth finish. Dont have to give so mush extra effort to blend it. Even perfectly blends without eye primer. For me its a good friend. Highly pigmented and so many gorgeous colors to pick from.
Friends makeup

1 review

Great palette for the Die hard friends collectors. Could it be any better? The colors show up wonderfully! The palette is nice and sleek and the mirror always has you feeling great with a "How you doin?"
L'Oréal Paris Colour Riche Eyeshadow 206 Mademoiselle Pink

1 review

Il y a longtemps que je n'avais pas acheté d'ombres à paupières car je les boudais. J'estimais qu'elles ne tenaient pas assez longtemps. J'ai maintenant trouvé celle qui me fait mentir. Elle tiendra toute la journée jusqu'à ce que je me démaquilles le soir. Elle est...
Bourjois Little Round Pot intense Extrait Shimmer Eyeshadow No. 03

1 review

Lovely shade which can be used a daytime despite of glitter added. It’s subtle for all occasions and styles. It’s neutral with hint of peach/pink colour and glitter. I use it every day to add a little sparkle to my look and to look fresh and natural. It’s small but last...
L'Oreal Paris Paradise Enchanted: Eyeshadow Palette

1 review

First off, the colours in this palette are beautiful. I did not use this with a primer, and it was very long-lasting with no fallout and great pigment. I was honestly surprised it lasted all day on me and still looked great. Great product at a great price.
Makeup Geek Secret Garden Duo-Chrome Eye Shadow

1 review

I think this is one of my favourite eye shadows of all time. It's a rich, emerald/forest green that shifts to a coppery brown or even a purplish-brown (depending on the colours around it). Easy to apply and looks best when applied with a finger over a wet base or glitter primer.
Makeup Geek Blacklight Duo-Chrome Eye Shadow

1 review

I love this duo-chrome eyeshadow. It shifts from a light purple to a blue-ish colour, depending on how the light hits it or what other colours you wear it with. It was one of my first MUG purchases and a big part of why I keep buying from them.
Blue Blood palette

5 reviews

This palette is absolutely beautiful. It's a little pricey, but I really don't mind. As always Jeffree brought high quality, pigmented, buttery shadows to this blue themed palette. The pans a large, the packaging is beautiful, and the large mirror is always welcome. The...
NYX Ultimate Brights Eyeshadow pallete

8 reviews

Nyx Ultimate Palette Instagram @littlemissbeauty.xo I use this palette weekly and will always be apart of my collection. The colours are very pigmented and very smooth applying. The packaging is beautiful so you dont need to open the palette to see the colours . This palette...