We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
141-160 of 1610

Wet n Wild Color Icon 10-Pan Nude Awakening Eyeshadow Palette

1 review

This is a fantastic eyeshadow palette. One of my favourites from wet n wild. The formula is fantastic with all the eyeshadows being creamy and super blendable. It is also incredibly pigmented but doesn't have much fallout at all. It also has a great range of colors in a compact...
Nyx off tropic eyeshadow palette

1 review

Its great! All thr colors are so bold and vibrant , they go on so smooth and almost all of them can be used for anything. The colors pair well with eachother they can be used on thier own for a more subtle daytime look or mix them up for a bright bold look. Definitley catches...
Makeup Geek Hot Pants Shimmer Eyeshadow

1 review

I love the way this looks in the pan (which is much more intense in person than in a photo) but it doesn't translate well to the eye. I tried applying with a brush, with my finger, over a wet base, over glitter primer, etc. but I couldn't get the colour pay-off I wanted. I...
The Balm What's the Tea The Buzz

1 review

I've been really into teals this summer so I jumped at this fantastic shade. I got it as a single in my Ipsy bag. It's a dark teal metallic shade. Buttery and smooth. Very pigmented. Looks great on its own, better with a primer or glitter glue.
morphe dare to create palette

8 reviews

I love the variety! You can do something bold and flashy, or keep it neutral. The metallics are so pigmented! This is my go to palette for the club or even events! It has good base neutrals so it even looks great for natural looks!
Tarte- pineapple of my eye

1 review

A little expensive for me but I am cheap. However, I believe you are getting what you paid for so many colors and so pigmented. I live for this palette and will use all of it.
IMN Veleteen Dream Eyeshadow

1 review

This was another Ipsy special. One of the better shadows I got from them. The formula ia really smooth and the shimmer is even. I did have to layer quite a bit but as a center lid shadow this is gorgeous. Doesn't blend the best but if you pack it on you can get a great color...
Tarte Grav3yardgirl Swamp Queen Palette

21 reviews

i bought this pallette because they were out if the other one that i really wanted ! However i was not disappointed ..the highlight shade in this pallette is GORGEOUS.. i wish they would sell it as a single shadow or even highlighter
ELLA EDEN Eyeshadow in Willow

1 review

This shade is absolutely BEAUTIFUL! I think it's now my favourite eye shadow I have ever used! It stays on all day long and still looked amazing by the end of the day! I will defiantly purchase this.
Makeup Revolution Unicorns Unite Salvation Eyeshadow Palette

1 review

I bought this unicorn unite palette this morning & tried it out tonight. I love the pigment, its easy to blend & is long lasting. I used a white primer before applying & it really made the colors pop!. Its a decent price for a great product.
Rimmel Magnifeyes Blush Edition eyeshadow

2 reviews

I tried three different pallet schemes in this brand, and in all three the pigmentation was poor, the staying power was poor (even with a primer), and it was just overall hard to apply. it went on blotchy and smeared easily. I would not recommend.
Hardcandy

3 reviews

love all Hard Candy cosmetics. They're very inexpensive and affordable. This product has a sponge top so that it's easy to use and you can twist the top so you dont waste product. Its lasted me for a very long time as I dont have to use it everyday.
Revlon photo ready primer, Shadow and sparkle

3 reviews

I have been using this one in different colors for about 4 years now and love it! The colors are realistic and stay put all day. You can still customize the shades somewhat as well. Overall, one to purchase again and again.
Beauty treats

1 review

I loved the colour selection 24 colours you really can’t go wrong. 13 glitter shades the rest Matt. They lasted the whole day wearing them. The pigment is there with these shadows there is a bit of fall out but not much.
Hard Candy Look Pro! Eyeshadow Palette

2 reviews

I bought the palette from walmart for under $15. It has a really great selection of colors both matte and shimmer. Can do all shimmer, or all matte colors. Can do analogous or complementary. Can do a matte snd shimmer combination. Really great pallette to work with with enough...
Iby No Running

1 review

I got this shadow as a single. It's a metallic light purple, almost pink eyeshadow. It has a slight bit of glitter in it too. I'm generally impressed with Iby eyeshadows, they are creamy, pigmented and last all day - even without a primer. Applies better with a finger, but...
Tarte Dream Big eye shadow

2 reviews

The shades in the Tarte Dream Big eyeshadow palette are gorgeous for nuetral everyday shades. They do have to be built up but using the right primer they work great. If you want to try a palette for a everyday look i do recommend trying this one.
Loreal lapalette nude 1

2 reviews

The palette is nice, these are all the shades that I would use regularly. The shadow blends in nicely, it’s almost like the urban decay naked. It’s it’s worth buying cuz your getting a good product at a reasonable price
essence my must haves eyeshadow 05 Cotton Candy

1 review

I love a pale pink sweep of shadow on my lids. This, however, is not my colour! I want to be clear here that I only dislike the colour. The shadow stays on really well. I just look a little like a clown who is trying too hard.
huda beauty palette rose gold

3 reviews

After seeing alot of bloggers and influencers rave about this eyeshadow I decided to take the plunge and buy it. I'm so glad I did the colours are beautiful and you can create so many different eye looks with it.