We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Mascara Reviews

If you ask any Chick what her #1 Beauty Must-Have Product is, she'll probably answer "Mascara".  It opens small eyes, adds definition to small sparse lashes, and polishes every look from daytime to playtime.  A quality mascara will lengthen, thicken, and darken the appearance of lashes for a bold and sexy finish.  You should replace your mascara after approximately 3 months to protect your eye health and minimize the clumping effects of old product.

ChickAdvisors love accessible brands like CoverGirl LashBlast, Maybelline New York Colossal, and L'Oreal Paris Voluminous mascaras.  Favourite upscale brands include Dior DiorShow, Benefit BadGal Lash, and Lancome Definicils High Definition mascaras.

Sort by:  DateRating
241-260 of 1067

Rimmel London Scandaleyes Show Off Mascara

23 reviews

I used this mascara a long time ago but I remember loving it. The ball thing on the end really helps get the inner corner lashes and the bottom ones to. It was a very black mascara. I have no memory of it flaking or smudging either. Never had a problem with it.
Rimmel London Lash Accelerator Serum

4 reviews

My eyelashes literally grew within two weeks of using this serum ! Even when I forgot to use it often I still saw results . However when I stopped , my lashes did not look as full as when I was using it ! So I knew it was the serum making them look great
Maybelline Great Lash Mascara in Royal Blue

18 reviews

I haven't tried coloured mascara until now. Was shopping @ Superstore 2 days ago. Saw shelves of cosmetics "$1.48 or under" so I rooted through everything and found this. Thought for a buck and change, I could experiment a little. You really have to cake it on to get any tinge...
Annabelle Cosmetics Expandable Mascara

14 reviews

I LOVE this mascara so much. The wand is amazing and I love that you can extend the brush to make the bristles further apart, I virtually only ever use it on the longest setting. The price is pretty dang good as well, I usually pay around $9 for it. I recently decided to try...
Kirkland Borghese Advanced Lash Defining Mascara

6 reviews

I have been using this mascara since high school. I honestly have never even been tempted to switch to another one because this works wonders for my eyelashes and helps them grow long and healthy.
COVERGIRL LashBlast Clump Crusher Water Resistant Mascara

74 reviews

This mascara is great if you don’t want any clumps, but it doesn’t lengthen THAT much. Also it tends to dry out pretty quickly. I usually combine it with another mascara that is more lengthening and it works great
Marcelle Twist Push Up Mascara

4 reviews

I like this mascara. At first I thought it was too gimmicky but after using it for about a month now I'm sold. The wand starts off in its full extended position, allowing you to cake on product for a nice voluminous look. Then, twist the cap and the brush rotates into a diagonal...
L'Oréal Paris Telescopic Shocking Extension Mascara

15 reviews

This is a great mascara is you're looking for something that gives you length and really separates your lashes. I tend to use this in conjunction with another mascara - one to give me volume and then this one to lengthen and separate. Because of the skinny applicator, you have a...
COVERGIRL Flamed Out Waterproof Mascara

15 reviews

I've been using CoverGirl Flamed Out waterproof Mascara for a few weeks and I'm not a huge fan of it. It's reasonably priced, but I find it a too clumpy when it's applied, which I dislike. I'll be trying something different the next time I grab Mascara.
Revlon Lash Potion Mascara

58 reviews

This mascara does not come off! I have severe anxiety and it stays on through panic attack after panic attack. Work of warning though, it's really hard to get off. Baby wipes won't cut it with this stuff.
Physicians Formula Organic Wear FakeOut Mascara

12 reviews

So I bought this because of the Organic ingredients and of course the beautiful bottle it came in. When I opened the bottle too put it on my eye lashes nothing even stuck on my eyelashes...I kept re-apply over and over and over and over and over and it was like a little thin...
NYC New York Color Big Bold Curl Mascara

38 reviews

I love this brand and all their products have been amazing. This makes my lashes look fuller and thicker and darker yet still natural. Great price and great results.
Khroma The Quickie Mascara

1 review

This mascara has everything you want in a formula: it curls, lengthens, and volumizes . Plus, it lasts all day without smudges or flakes.
Maybelline Volum' Express the Colossal Cat Eyes Mascara

73 reviews

I would not buy this again. It does give the cat eye effect but it takes so many applications to get it and I feel it is so dry. I also feel it does not last long.
L'Oreal Paris Double Extend Waterproof Mascara

2 reviews

This is the best mascara I have ever tried!! It's better then any high end product I have used and a reasonable price. It makes my lashes look like I get false lash extensions done AND it lasts through just about everything. I even have a hard time washing it off if I'm not...
Maybelline New York Full and Soft Waterproof Mascara

3 reviews

This is one of the best waterproof mascara I have ever tried. Bought it for my Miami trip, and I wore it ALL THE TIME, and it didn't wash off, although I was in the pool at all times or it was raining.
Maybelline New York Lash Discovery Mini Brush Washable Mascara

2 reviews

This mascara is great for the lower lash line and inner corner, it really defines and pulls out even the smallest of lashes. I have even used this on my top lashes, and it really defines the lashes ( but it took a really long time to put on because the wand was so small.) This...
Max Factor 2000 Calorie Straight Brush Mascara

2 reviews

This is good value, easy to apply, quite suprised for price of good product, it was long lasting wear, made my lashes longer and good for daytime as not too dramatic
Maybelline New York Volum' Express Big Eyes Mascara

107 reviews

Maybelline is my go to product for mascara. Been using the brand forever and try all the new ones that come out. Fun to try it and they stay on for a good period of time.
Maybelline Volum' Express The Rocket Waterproof Mascara

45 reviews

Love this stuff! This actually holds the curl on my short, stick straight lashes all day. The plastic applicator really separates and define my lashes while the formula of the mascara really adds mega volume.