Yay or Nay? Hilary Swank's Red Carpet Style

In theory, Hilary Swank's outfit at the premiere of New Year's Eve has everything that I love. She's elegant in a jewel tone shade and sophisticated with just the right amount of sheer and sequins. That being said, there is something holding me back from really loving this look.

I think it's the weird choice of sleeve. Tell me I'm not the only one who notices the bat wings? A loosely tied together bow at the waist over a sheer overlay, is not the best look. There is way too much fabric on her very athletic and slim frame. I really hate this because cut a different way, or even styled differently, this would be totally chic!
However, I do need to give a shout out to Hilary's hair and make up team- girl looks beautiful! I read some complaints on her shoe choice, but here I diverge, I actually really like them. They're interesting enough to make a statement but don't take away from the dress.
What do you think- are the bat wings blinding your judgement too? Is this a yay or nay?
(images via zimbio.com)
More on Celebrities, Contests
Facebook Comments
91 Comments
![]() |
on December 18, 2011
meredith
said:
I like it, very pretty |
![]() |
|
![]() |
on December 17, 2011
hideouslyheather
1,039
said:
YAY !! I think she looks fabulous. It seems like - if everyone isnt dressed the same, then they are weird .. I love the see thru material and how this dress looks, its a great colour and she is wearing it well |
![]() | Nay! The sleeves ruin the dress. Otherwise it may have looked nice but there is just too much going on. |
![]() | I like the idea of it, but the overlay should have been a closer cut. The blue is gorgeous though. |
![]() | I would say yay if the top of the dress was strapless or sleeveless; the shawl like drape on the top doesn't look too nice. |
![]() | Nay...the sleeves are horrible. |
![]() | I love the dress but since it's so gauzy and billowy, a solid colour shoe would stick out better. I think she looks faaab. |
![]() |
on December 16, 2011
BlondeBrittany
1,000
said:
Yay.... but her makeup nay... I really don't like it... and she could have picked better shoes.. maybe like red heels would have been a nice pop of colour! |
![]() | Nay |