We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Members' Faves: Eyeliner

Posted by Tammy | Tuesday August 30, 20114 comments

If someone asks me the question "What is the one make-up you cannot live without?" My answer is always- eyeliner. Eyeliner has been used for centuries to define the eyes and to create a variety of illusions. For instance, eyeliner makes your eyes pop and appear larger. Eyeliner had became an essential tool in a woman's life so we need to know which ones are worth spending our hard earned cash on! Below is a list of all the eyeliners that our chicks are recommending in no particular order.

1. Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner
"I was prone to using liquid liner or pencil based liners. As a contact eyes lens wearer, my eyes get dry and at time itchy. I often find myself rubbing my eye, or re-adjusting the contact lens. With the Bobbi Brown long wear eye liner, it doesn't fade after 8-10hours of wear if you do not touch your eyes. It does not smudge into your crease like other liners. With the eye liner brush from Bobbi Brown, it gives you a smooth and mistake free application. I highly recommend! The colors are fantastic as well. I am currently loving Mauve and Black Ink." - WikkedWindy

2. L'Oreal HIP High Intensity Pigments Color Truth Cream Eyeliner
"I was browsing Chickadvisor for eyeliner suggestions, and the reviews for this particular product determined me to give it a try. In general I am not a huge fan of Loreal brand products, but I've gotta say, I am super impressed. I wanted an eyeliner, that it's easy to apply, that can give me a clean look without that harsh line of a liquid eyeliner, something that won`t smudge or wash away or flake or crumble... and cream eyeliner is the only version left for me to try out. I love the texture, creamy and rich, doesn't crumble or crack or flake. I love the fact that it`s so much easier to apply, it goes on smooth, gives you a clean line without looking too harsh. I love love love this eyeliner…" - Ra143

3. Annabelle Kohl Eyeliner
"This product was amazing. It goes on very smoothly, and shows up nicely. The best part is IT LASTS!! The colour stays bold all day :)" - teenagedirtbagg

4. Maybelline New York Define-A-Line Eyeliner
"I love the fact that you don't have to worry about having a sharpener handy all the time and there's no risk of accidentally scratching your cornea with that bit of wood you didn't see sticking out the end (tell me I'm not the only one). It always goes on smoothly and is perfect for achieving a smokey eye since it comes with a sponge built in." - Marayna

5. MAC Fluidline
"This is BY FAR the best liner on the market. The formula is gel-based so you get the really sharp black look, without the smudging of a pencil, or wetness of a liquid. It stays put, you have the option of a really thin precise line or a thicker more dramatic shape, and it comes in dozens of beautiful shades! Love this product - especially for drawing over a false lash strip!" - Melissa Andre

1. Revlon ColorStay Eye Liner
"I looove this eyeliner! I got mine free on a tube of Revlon Mascara, and initially just tossed it aside as yet another black eyeliner. I was so wrong! This eyeliner is really smooth and applies with little to no effort at all. You can apply it any way (ie. thick, thin, smudged, on the waterline) and it will stay in place for hours. I can't say enough about how great this eyeliner is. Better yet, it's a twist up, so you don't have to fight to sharpen it. How many times have you ended up using a different eyeliner than the one you actually wanted because it wasn't sharpened ans you were in too much of a rush to be bothered to sharpen it? Exactly. Not an issue with these, and they a handy little sharpening tool hidden in the bottom of the tube to get that fresh out of the package tip." - Spoony

2. Rimmel London Soft Kohl Kajal Eye Pencil
"When it comes to pencil eyeliner this product is the best I have ever found. Even compared to brands like Estee Lauder, Rimmel beats them all hands down. The product is not as cheap as brands like NYC, however for the few extra dollars you get more than your moneys worth. It is easy sharpening. Goes on smooth and where you want it. It has minimal smudging (unless you purposely smudge it for effect), and very long lasting. The best eyeliner out there in my opinion. A good buy, good value. You won't regret this purchase, it will easily become one of your favorites and a staple in your routine." - Chez392

3. Avon Glimmersticks Eye Liner
"What can I say? I LOVE Avon Glimmersticks Waterproof Eyeliner! I purchase this whenever it goes on sale- which is often with Avon, and it's the only eyeliner I buy. I have it in black, plum, gray and dark blue with the basic black being my fave. It is truly waterproof and has great staying power. You turn the product up which means NO messy sharpening.
I highly recommend this eyeliner!" - iAmBrendaLee

4. Maybelline New York Define-A-Line Eyeliner
"I've used every type of eye-liner out there: pencil, liquid, gel, etc. Lately all I've been using is this eyeliner. I love the fact that you don't have to worry about having a sharpener handy all the time and there's no risk of accidentally scratching your cornea with that bit of wood you didn't see sticking out the end (tell me I'm not the only one). It always goes on smoothly and is perfect for achieving a smokey eye since it comes with a sponge built in." - Marayana

5. Stila Smudge Pots
"These smudge pots really do what they're supposed to do! I have this in Bronze and it is a gorgeous color! The packaging is nice and although the price paid is quite high, you actually do get a lot of product which lasts you for quite some time. I have been using this as my eyeliner for a long time and I found that it was super easy to apply with a small angled brush. The product literally lasts all day and even if you do a bit of rubbing, it doesn't move until you take it off with makeup remover. You can also use this product as a base for your eyeshadows to make it stay and last longer. Overall, I LOVE this product and would highly recommend it!" - xagnes

If you have a favorite eyeliner that you want to recommend and is not in this list, feel free to write a review.

Do you agree with our members? Let us know down below!
More by Tammy
More on Eyes, Lips, Face

Facebook Comments


on August 30, 2011  jlgoneboatin  2,418 said:

I absolutley recommend mac gel eyeliner, it comes in great trendy colours along with the basic ones, Easy to use and to smudge!! LOVE IT

on August 30, 2011  TammyK  1,073 said:

I definitely will have to try the L'Oreal cream liner. I heard so many good things about it.

on August 30, 2011  Becky  13,128 said:

L'Oreal did such an awesome job with their cream liner!! Very pigmented, glides on smoothly, doesn't crumble off. Even the brush it comes with is really useful.

on August 30, 2011  goodbyeglitter  527 said:

I love Fluidline and Revlons

Add Comment:

Blog URL: