We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eyeliner Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
1-20 of 902

NYX Professional Makeup 2-in-1 Liner & Lash Adhesive

165 reviews

Loved this NYX eyeliner pen as I am a fan of the pen style eyeliners for the top lash line because they are easy to work with when you want a precise, even line with a bit of a flick whilst being mess free, this also dries down to a long lasting and stay-put line that only...
Obsidian Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

1 review

I received this as part of my #Ipsy order. I do t wear a lot of eyeliner, but this one I found super easy to apply. Good quality, and stay power…. Perhaps too much. I found it a little hard to wash off. Lol
Revolution The Liner

1 review

I bought this as I wanted to create a flick and I didn’t have my favourite Benefit Roller Liner. This is a great alternative. I like that I can get really close to my upper lashes and that I can create a thin line or thick line depending on how I hold the pen. The ability...
Lola Automatic Eye Pencil - Grey

1 review

I am on a mission to find a dark grey not charcoal eyeliner. I bought this in the hopes it would be but unfortunately it is more silver than grey and glittery/shimmery. I wanted matte finish as I feel personally that shimmery/glittery don’t suit this 43-year old’s wrinkly...
benefit they're real push up liner

1 review

I am an addict. I love all the colours of They’re Real Push Up Liner if I am honest I would love them to create/make a charcoal grey liner. Holding the tip close to my eyelashes I can draw a line – firstly to get used to it I would press along the lash line to create a thin...
Benefit Roller Eye Bright Highlighter Pencil

1 review

Having seen this on Instagram, I bought it from Benefits UK website. I had bought it before I was told that I shouldn’t wear anything in my waterline which I have tried, and my eyes were red and very sensitive. I apply it to the inner corner of my eye and had no problems. I...
Benefit Badgal Bang 24 hour Eye Pencil - Blue

1 review

I have in the past used coloured eyeliners but have always gone back to either black or brown. I liked but not love the They’re Real Eyeliner, I found I had issues with the green, blue and purple eyeliners. I wasted more on a sheet of tissue than I had put on my eye. They...
Inglot gel eyeliner

1 review

I recently discovered this product after someone suggested I give it a try and I’m so impressed! It’s easy to apply and provides a very vivid color. The only downside would be that for me it tended to smudge even when using a primer and setting spray. Overall it’s...
PYT Beauty Wingman Liquid Liner

1 review

The staying power is 🔥🔥🔥! I tried this on when my husband and I went out for some shopping errands. My dry eyes were excessively watering (literally crying) due to the dry winter air and this liner did not smudge at all! It lasted me all day without moving! It has a...
COVERGIRL Exhibitionist Lash Enhancing Liquid Liner

1 review

I received this product in exchange for my honest opinion. I usually don’t wear liquid liner, because I always have a hard time with it. I have had several, and they either bleed (a little, or a lot) after application or bits peel off/it smudges throughout the day. I was...
Manna Kadar Eyedyllic eyeliner pencil

2 reviews

Crayon rétractable polyvalent, facile a travailler, crémeux et bien pigmenté, il tiens bien toute la journée et se démaquille facilement .De qualité très ordinaire sans plus.
eye liner MKI

1 review

L'eye liner numéro 01 de chez la marque MKI est l'un des premiers eye liners que j'ai utilisé, et reste l'un de mes préférés, car il est très facile a utiliser avec une pointe assez rigide et une tenue impressionnante !
Estee Lauder Little Black Liner

1 review

In the shade "onyx". Really gorgeous and looks amazing. has two different tips. One is ultra fine which is a pointy tip and the other is Thin/Thick with thick horizontal tip. Not as smudge proof but works for the whole day.
Araceli ojos perfectos gel eyeliner

1 review

I have tried a few of these and really enjoyed them. They glide on nicely with no tugging or skipping and are opaque. They stay put all day and remove easily with eye makeup remover. Definitely recommend these!! I have tried gold, sangria and navy.
KVD tattoo eyeliner

1 review

I received a sample of the Kat Von D (KVD) eyeliner in a cosmetic kit from Ulta. It goes on really smooth. It does not smear easily. It stays all day where I put it.
Better Than Sex Easy Glide Waterproof Liquid Eyeline

1 review

My favorite eyeliner ever, this was recommended to me by a staff member at sephora and I've never looked back since. It's super duper black.. like as black as your soul lol but seriously it's gorgeous it glides on like butter and the felt tip pen style makes for the sharpest...
Ionic Phat Smokey Chubby Stick

1 review

I bought the ioni Phat Smokey Chubby Stick from Dollartree Canada for $1.40. It is well worth it. It is easy to use and creates a great Smokey eye using a blending brush. It is great for smudging out the crayon.
The Quick Flick

1 review

I am envious of those who can do the perfect flick day in day out as I cannot. I have tried numerous times to do it and it just does not work. What I like about this is that you can get different thickness and colours – I bought the grand point in intense black. As it is a...
Tropics eyeliner

1 review

Tropics black eyeliner stays on all day cost about £16 but is worth it and lasts months. I’ve used loads of different eyeliners over the years but they all smudge and are gone before the day is finished tropics eyeliner lasts all day and no smudging. Would 100% recommend this
Rimmel London - Wonder'Ink Eyeliner

3 reviews

It’s so good like really good I would tell people to get it because of how good this thing is it blew my mind it’s absolutely insane how excellent it is