Okay I do like this product but not enough to buy it again so that says alot.
You see a slight difference when using it, Like it doesn't really make your lashes long and i see no lenght
The wite part when you use it still shows up even after you put on the black soo i wouldn't recomend it.
IT SUCKS!!

All in all, an awesome product. Really -does- extend lashes, even the shortest ones. The two step process is a little bit of a pain, but my eyelashes always feel softer after using this mascara vs. others. It's easy to wash off, and when you look at the cloth/cotton pad/whatever you use to take your make-up off, you can definitely see little strings of black...indicating that there really ARE little tubes on the end of your lashes. Probably one of the best mascaras I've ever had.

Well, I've been wanting to try the "tube" mascara for a while...so I finally went and got Beauty Tubes. It's a bit pricier than other drugstore mascara brands, but not by much. What I love about this mascara is that it will not smudge or flake off during the day and is a snap to remove in the shower! I love seeing the little tubes wash off in warm water. It comes with a white primer side which really lengthens your lashes and a black side that creates the tubes. When I'm in a rush, I just use the black side. And sometimes I use the white primer to add length and finish with a volumizing mascara, like Covergirl Lash Blast. The trick is to apply the black mascara immediately after you apply the primer--don't wait for it to dry, or it will clump. Overall, this mascara adds amazing length (but not much volume) and would be great for an everyday, natural look. Definitely worth a try.

This makes my lashes so long and really opens up my eyes. It comes off very easy when washing your face.

When I saw the commercial I actually went straight to the store (Target) to see what these 'Beauty Tubes' were all about...

The white applicator is to prime your lashes, coating them with a layer that gives your lashes extensions.
The black applicator is to set them and add color. I chose Very Black. after applying the Black your lashes look amazing!

My lashes looked wonderful and much longer, they held their volume and curl all day, no smudges or irritation.

clean up is a breeze. No messy remover or overdrying under your eyes from rubbibg. You can simply wash the extensions away in the shower with warm water or when doin your nightly face routine before bed. it may look like your actual lashes are coming out, but no worries its just the 'beauty tubes'

I couldn't believe what a difference this made to my lashes. The white primer is very interesting to put on, a bit mesmerizing as it sticks to your lashes. The dark colour wand puts a nice coating of colour on the lashes. I have parked my Maybelline mascaras and use this all the time now. It doesn't smear during the day but washes off cleanly without much effort. Note about what you see in the sink... when the mascara washes off it looks like your eyelashes are falling off... it is just the L'Oreal mascara tubes... but the first time seeing the wee black floaters was a bit shocking ;) Really good stuff, I recommend it highly.

love this stuff so far it is the only thing i have used that actually gives me lashes

I LOVE this product. Unlike some of the other girls that have tried this product, I've never had a problem with clumping or anything. I was amazed at how easily the mascara came off, and since I don't own makeup remover I'm happy to report that I no longer have that raccoon look after I wash my face. I found that this mascara did indeed lengthen my lashes... perfect.

I was so excited to get this mascara. I had been using a lengthening mascara [also with a primer] by Maybeline, but the commercial for Lash Tubes put it to shame. After giving it a couple of tries, I am back to using the Maybeline brand. Yes, it gave my lashes a bit of volume and length ... it also gave them sticky clumps. And the tubes were a real pain to get off ... you have to slightly pull them off with a moist cleansing pad or washrag and I am sure that some of my own lashes came off too. Even though the model in the commercial is obviously sporting false lashes, it's still a perfect example of false advertising in my book.

i LOVED THIS PRODUCT.IT GIVES NICE LENGTH AND VOLUME TO MY LASHES.IT DONT SMUDGE AND STAYS ON FOR LONG.IT CAN BE EASILY REMOVED WITH WARM WATER.