Average

I would say that this mascara is average and works just like any other over the counter mascara. The price goes with the quality of the product for sure when it comes to this product. I did not find that it added any additional length and or volume, but for a base mascara it was good.

Hate it

I hate it it doesn't do anything for my lashes if you have long lashes it will make them clump together and even fall out not worth it it's cheap for a reason

It's a really good price for a backup mascara in your purse, but the staying power isn't all that great.
I'd give it about 5 hours before I have raccoon eyes.

I will start by saying that I love e.l.f. products! I am disappointed in this mascara. It does kind of lengthen my lashes,but you can't tell that there's mascara on at all! I bought the black and if you didn't know any better, you'd swear I wasn't wearing any at all. I was quite surprised because, as I mentioned, I use a lot of e.l.f. products and haven't been disappointed yet! It's too bad given the price point, but I won't be purchasing this product again.

If you are on a budget but still want decent product Elf is USUALLY the way to go. Maybe I just happened to grab one of those tubes that is old, but I found this particular product to be to watery for it's claim of 3 in 1. I found i had to put a few layers on to get the desired results. Even on a budget I tossed this tube in the bottom of the drawer and proceeded to purchase my normal go to mascara. After this experience I haven't tried this product again.