I actually let my stepdaughter use this because I feel too old for it and she is totally into her eyebrows! She loved it and it looked very nice on her. Some of the products she has used in the past make it look like she has painted her eyebrows on. With a little help and a few words she did a wonderful job and the product went on nice and even and smooth and we liked the colour.

I'm not a huge fan of brow gel. It never seems to stay in place for me. I find with the heat we have and how natural warm I am. It just kinda melts off over the day.

I only used this one a few times because I found it goes on super strong and makes my eyebrows look completely unnatural. I also didn't actually receive a pencil, I received the pencil gel, which actually looks like mascara, same type of brush and everything. I usually use a light brow pencil just to slightly enhance my eyebrows, i have red hair so my eyebrows are fairly light, so the gel enhances them way too much. Maybe it would work better for people with dark colour eyebrows, but now good for light brows.

Of the 4 prodducts I received with the #GoshGoodness package, I really didn't like this product at all. The package was to be a pencil with a brush, but I actually received a gel macsara wand and not a pencil with a brush. I found that it didn't really take to my brows (which are pretty dark already), and took a little long to dry. The first day I tried this, I actually rubbed my eyebrow because it felt moist and kind of tickled.. this smudged the colour. Also, it again felt moist later in the humid weather. I have never used this type of brow pencil before, and really didn't like it. I much prefer an actual pencil with brush over the wet gel product. The one positive I can give is that again, it didn't react with my sensitive skin nor did it leave a dry sensation.

I'm always on the hunt for good brow products and I fill mine in and darken them daily. While it was easy to find a colour match with Gosh, I'm not crazy about the pencil, I find I have to go over multiple times to get it dark enough and it is tough to get even colour. For the price ($12) it isn't my fav.