I am glad to have the chance to demo this product before purchase, as it doesn't quite do the trick for me.
The Stileto has great packaging and a nice cool look but as far as the product goes...its just average. I liked that it wasn't too clumpy after a few coats on my lashes, but they didn't seem too long or thick. Also this is not waterproof and easily wahses off with water and soap etc. I would never wear this to a sad movie or to the beach! It probably has more appeal for someone desiring a nataural look without much thickening or lengthening to the lashes. Average!

I was really excited to try this new mascara, especially since the packaging looks so sleek! However, I was a little disappointed that the effect wasn't as exciting as its packaging. While I don't recall any claims for "bolder" lashes or "100 times volume", what it does claim to do is lengthen lashes. I guess in a sense it does lengthen lashes as any product that coats your lashes would - it just makes your lashes stand out more. Nothing special. Nothing extraordinary. I would personally prefer mascaras that make your lashes look fuller.

For those who prefer a more natural look, you may want to try this product. What I like about it is that it's not clumpy, and looks barely-there. The flipside then is that, well, it's barely there! Not very dramatic, so might not be enough for an evening glam look. It's good for wearing to the office though. Mind you, I only apply one coat, so perhaps results would be different with a 2nd coat?

I haven't had any problems washing it off. Usually comes off clean with regular cleanser and water, unlike my previous mascara where I couldn't get away without first using eye makeup remover.

Overall, if you're looking for inexpensive day-wear mascara or something more natural, you should give this a try. If you're looking to be wowed, I'd suggest trying another product.

I was very excited to receive this as part of the product review club but I was quite disappointed in it. The price is fair and since it's Maybelline, it'll be easy to locate.
The packaging is cute and I like the name, and the red hint reminds me of my favorite stiletto heel designer, Christian Louboutin.

However, I don't think the product lives up to its name. It claims to have good lengthening abilities. I applied it as directed, and did not let the layers dry in between. I found by the time I was able to develop any length, my lashes were getting very clumpy. If I did not put on enough coats, the mascara was too natural looking for me and did not have a "wow" lenghtening factor.

It is easy to remove and I did not have problems with smudging. With the many options there are on the market, I would not buy this one personally.

I received this mascara as part of the Product Review Club and was really excited to try it....too bad it didn't deliver. In a market where most mascaras are delivering double-duty such as lengthening AND volumizing or lengthening AND curling, this mascara is a one-trick pony. To be fair, the mascara is only marketed as a lengthening mascara, but it doesn't lengthen lashes exceptionally well. I've used mascaras that lengthens better and personally, I want my mascara to do more than that. I don't know how much this mascara is, but I'm sure its comparable to other drugstore brands that deliver more. Don't bother trying this mascara out it's not worth it.

I recieved this from the product review club and thought that it worked pretty well and there were no problems whatsoever. I found that it passed the test when it came to not giving the effect of a raccon eye and there seemed to be no smudges when applied. I also have to add tha tI like the stilleto theme design for the mascara ;) Even if it's not the best I've tried I would totally recommend it !!!

I received this as a part of the product review.

Packaging and the shape of the tube is nice. Nice and slender to fit into any purse.
This mascara lengthens lashes, but that's about it. Even with numerous coats, the result is not very apparent.

I've seen this product on shelves down in the states and it retails for about $8USD. I wouldn't recommend this product, you're better off spending your money elsewhere.

This mascara did not really wow me at all. I've given it a shot a few times now, and it just did not get the job done.

Some things I did like about the Lash Stiletto Mascara was the packaging. Maybelline has been doing a top job in that department lately. I like that the bottle is thin (as opposed to the thick bottle the colossal has), as it takes up less space in my makeup bag. As well, the thin wand makes for easy application. This mascara also did not clump my lashes together, which is a big problem I have with most.

The things I didn't really like about this mascara is that it provided no volume whatsoever to my lashes. I felt as though it looked like I wasn't really wearing any mascara at all. It was somewhat hard to notice it. While it did add a bit of curl to my lashes in the beginning, they fell flat very quickly. As for the promise of long lashes, I don't think this product delivered. After about 3 coats my lashes were lacking both volume and length.

I don't think I will be buying this product in the future. I'll be sticking to Maybelline's Colossal Volum' Express instead.

Very sexy and chic on the outside, but doesn't deliver on the inside.

This mascara claims to lengthen lashes and contains a combination of lengthening ‘polymers to stretch the lash'; however I measured my upper and lower lashes, before and after application, hoping to believe their claim. End result--no difference.

This produces a natural-looking effect, so when this mascara comes out in January, those wishing to have long lengths to their lashes like a stiletto does to legs, should look elsewhere.

This mascara comes in an attractive package and the name is cool too but the product is just ok. It goes on smooth and covers well but didn't hold my curl; it weighed down my lashes. I won't be switching mascaras to this one. I find L'Oreal Volumous better overall.

Like everyone else, I got this mascara as part of the Product Review Club. Also like everyone else, I love the packaging.

But the mascara itself is just okay. Not bad, but not amazing. The first time I used it, I applied two coats (the packaging recommends multiple applications). I won't do that again - it was so clumpy. The next few times I used it, I only put on one coat, and it wasn't clumpy at all. The wand does a good job of separating the lashes. But I found it didn't make my lashes any fuller.