This is based on my experience with the Waterproof version in blackest black

Pros:
- It gave me some length giving a nice fluttery lash effect
- It held my curl well
- Very black
- brush shape was good for overall application and the thin tip was good for hard to reach corners
- coated lashes effectively
- didn't clump
- separated my lashes nicely

Cons:
- smudged a little after 6 hours but I have oily lids
- smells bad (I find most mascaras do) but this one had was quite strong
- bristles were hard and pokey so I avoided getting too close to my lash line

Overall this is a good everyday mascara and I really liked the look of my lashes with this mascara plus the packaging is quite sleek. I would definitely repurchase!

this mascara went above and beyond! literally, its wonderful. my eyelashes were so great and long. i want to totally reccomend this for anyone looking for good mascara.

amazing mascara product. it makes my lashes thicker and longer looking which is greatly needed. great price point and effectiveness is great as well.

Amazing with length. Costs about 6 to 8 dollars, depending on where you get itand any sales, and worth every pennie! In fact, it's a steal! Washable, lasts all day, and does'nt clump! AT ALL! Does everything it says it should do, in style. The continer is looks like a cute little stilletto heel, and the brush is thin and very defined bristles.

Why does every drugstore mascara have a big, fat wand? I can't control them, which is why I stick with Lash Stiletto. The tapered wand allows me to reach the little lashes hiding at the corners. It dries soft, with a little gloss to it, and doesn't get dry or brittle. Has a nice smell to it (rose?), which I like, as most mascaras smell chemical-ly. Doesn't flake off - I've worked 12 hour days wearing this and it really doesn't budge. Washes off easily with soap and water. I can get a more dramatic look if I layer thin coats, but I prefer the natural length Lash Stiletto provides. I'll try new mascaras, because I can't resist the temptation, but this product remains part of my routine.

This mascara really does what says. it makes your eyelashes fuller, and longer

Once upon a time, Maybelline made Illegal Lengths, the ultimate lengthening mascara. Too bad it had an unhappy ending when it spontaneously disappeared from store shelves. Lash Stiletto is the sequel. This mascara has crazy lengthening properties likely from the brush – “Grip & Extend" – which reaches each lash to coat them evenly in a black-patent shine.

Full review: http://gracefulglutton.blogspot.com/2010/06/lashes-lash-stiletto-by-maybelline.html

This mascara improved the appearance of my short, barely there lashes almost as well as Lancome Definicils for a third of the price. I found the scent to be rather strong and slightly offensive, but it would not deter me from using this affordable product.

I find that usually lengthening mascaras dont give much volume as well but this one did and no clumping, will definatley buy again

This is one of the best mascaras out there for the price. I have short to medium length eyelashes and I have tried almost every mascara out there and this is one of my favorites. I only need about 2 full coats to get the length I want. Highly recommend <3