I was very disappointed to find this mascara very, very dry. I'm not sure if it was old or if it is really just dry to begin with, but it was not usable for me. I have fine lashes and I couldn't even get the mascara to coat my lashes.

This is terrible mascara, the brush is nice but the mascara itself flakes horribly and smudges like nobody's business. What a waste of $

I tried this Mascara and it was awful! I don't wear a lot of makeup and this stuff clumped up like no tomorrow and made it look like I had caked on the product. I would not recommend this product to anyone. There are much better options out there.

This is a horrible mascara. It creates volume by clumping and lashes stick together. When I applied it I felt like there was a heavy weight to my lashes all day. It also smears. I do not recommend buying it.

Ok, another mascara review.

This mascara is ANNOYING to use. (The waterproof version does its job though). It is soo clumpy, I think of tar whenever I use it. It is so thick that I have trouble getting it on my eyelashes! I've run the wand on the side of the tube of mascara, still struggling to get in on my actual lashes - ain't nobody got time for dat!! Once you get it on...it smudges. Granted, I am generous in my application as I love mascara but I'm constantly having to 'fix it' throughout the day.

I give this mascara a loud: whomp, whomp, whomp, whooooooooomp! sound as a review.

All I want is to a mascara that wants to be on my eyelashes and STAY on my face till I want it off. Is that too much to ask?

PS- If you have the patience, the Waterproof one is AMAZING and will stay on your eyes till the Apocalypse is over.

Was not impressed with this product at all. First the applicator brush I found too big, which if you have short lashes and need to have the "falsie" look, can be difficult to apply? I found that the mascara was clumpy when applied to the brush from tube, and also clumped on my lashes.

the wand is really big, you get massive clumps. it gives you very bulky looking lashs

This is probably the worst mascara that I have ever purchased. I was under the impression that it would be a fabulous one to try, as the reviews are mostly great. But, I was very disappointed. I purchased the waterproof. First, I'm going to start off on a positive note. The waterproof is actually waterproof. For the life of me, I could not wash off this mascara. So, if you are someone looking for a good waterproof mascara, this one's for you. With that said, I literally could NOT wash it off. I scrubbed my eyes, until it hurt. I used soap & water, make up removal clothes, make up remover liquids.. Nothing worked. A little would come off, but it was still caked on my lashes. I literally had to use my finger nails, and pull the mascara off my lashes.. I lost quite a few in the battle. I also found that it made my lashes hurt. I'm not sure if the mascara was pulling really hard at the roots or what, but it was quite painful to wear. After awhile it would numb down, but ouch! Definitely never wearing it again.

I was not impressed by this mascara. It is very thick and clumped when applied. I didnt like the brush either.

It was a little difficult using this because the formula is dry and it's clumpy. It does not make my lashes look good at all.