I like this mascara, i purchased this in the waterproof fomula and i think it holds my stick straight asian lashes quite well. At the end of the day it sumdges a tinsy tiny bit on my bottom lashline.but its not that noticeable.In my opinion it doesnt give much volume, hence the name. D: The pros of this mascara is that the bristles are soft, doesnt clump,and it holds the curl. The packaging is really pretty too!
The cons of this mascara is that it doesnt give me the volume and it seems like any other mascara..
Overall its a nice mascara and i would repurchase it because it doesnt clump,but im someone that likes to try different mascaras.