this product pulled me in with its pretty bronze packaging and claims of smooth application and volume. Ugh no, it was so dry i could hear it making a scratchy noise! haha and it made black flakes fall all over my cheeks the first time i applied it. not impressed. i used it a couple times and now it sits collecting dust on my vanity, sigh I really wanted to love it but not meant to be! see my full review on youtube at this link: https://youtu.be/pGP6u6T_1RA

This is one of the worst mascara's I've ever used. 15 minutes after applying it is still wet and leaving track marks all over my eyes, and it claims to be clump free, it's not. I would not recommend it.