I found this eye makeup remover to be one of the better Simple products. Was very effective @ removing eye makeup, but did leave a bit of an oily film after using, but not a big deal.

This Eye Make-up Remover effectively removes even waterproof mascara, it took me a few tries to get my waterproof mascara off but it is great for eyeshadow and eyeliners

I really wanted to like this - I usually enjoy simple products and they typically work well for me. But this didn't remove my makeup very well - it moreso smudges it around and I have to wash my face anyway, which kind of defeats the purpose.

I've used this product in the past and I have to say that it is not my favorite. I found it didn't do a good job at removing my mascara or eyeliner, and it often left behind a slightly oily film and smudged mascara. I prefer L'oreal's micellar water or Neutrogena's eye makeup remover to this.

I'm all for products with simple ingredients...when they work. Unfortunately, I found Simple's eye makeup remover to be too gentle of a formula. I had to wipe VERY thoroughly to actually get all of the makeup off - so much so that I felt like I undid all of the 'gentle' properties it claims by being so harsh. Simply not effective enough compared to other brands I've used.

I saw alot of positive review about this product, but unfortunately I did not like it! It did not work for me the same way most other makeup removers do. I had to scrub me face which was not fun. I am used to using coconut oil which removes the makeup in pretty much one swipe. I unfortunately will not be buying this again

I do not have sensitive skin by any means, and can usually get away with using nearly any product. I purchased the Simple Eye Makeup Remover on a whim, and am sad to say that I don't think I'll be able to finish the bottle.

From day one, my eyes are left irritated and stinging after using this product. I use it in the same manner as all of my other eye makeup removers, putting it onto a cotton pad to remove my mascara, then washing my face and applying my toner/serum/lotions before bed. If I have used the Simple Eye Makeup Remover, my eyes will tear up and sting for about 20 minutes after use, even after washing my face. This only happens when using this particular product.

I've read over the ingredients list, and have come to the conclusion that I must have a sensitivity to one of the ingredients. Otherwise, it is odd that a product specifically formulated to be gentle would give me issues, when regular products have never caused any concern.

On another note, I sadly do not find this product to be effective at removing mascara. It does a fine job with brow powder and eyeshadow, but I prefer an oil based eye makeup removed to dissolve and remove my mascara and eye liner without causing me irritation.

Sorry Simple, but this product just doesn't work for me!

I have to be honest with my reviews and im doing just that. The price and ingredients are nice but it stings my eyes =(

I loved that it was gentle on my eyes but I found you had to use it several times to remove my water-proof mascara. Easily removes eyes shadow and liner. Would use again.

After becoming a huge fan of the SImple cleansing wipes, I thought I'd give this a try for those days that I need something more heavy duty to remove my macara, gel eyeliner, and layers of shadow. Disappointed. I need to use about three cotton pads to fully remove any residue (or so I thought) and I am still waking up with raccoon eyes every morning.