My optometrist recommended these to me after she found out that I don't remove make up very well under my eye lid area. I gave these a try and they definitely work to solve that problem, but the wipes are SOOOOO soapy that I feel like I'm being messy trying to get clean. The wipes are also too big - I only need a fraction of what it is to give my two lids a wipe. It definitely seemed more like a waste to use it