
Best of Butterly® Winner: 202499% OF CHICKS DIG IT
A lovely lipstick to replace your lip balm
The lipsticks I received came in fully recyclable cardboard boxes, while the tubes themselves seem to be completely made of plastic (can we bring back metallic lipstick tubes and just purchase the inside piece, please?) YSL does packaging really well; I have really enjoyed whipping these babies out. I feel like the ultimate glam gal and loving the feeling. The lipstick’s texture is borderline lip balm texture, and I’m totally here for it. It smells divine—like a juicy cold nectarine you’ve just bitten into (can you tell I am very eager for summer?) It hydrates amazingly well; I haven’t had to reach for my lip balm at all a single time this week. And I don’t get that weird taste at the back of my throat that I get with some lipsticks, thankfully. Goodness, I hate that taste so much.
Both colors I received from Butterly were close to my natural lip color. The Nude Lingerie gave my lips a pinkish hue, while the Nude Lavallière turned them a little darker, with both adding a lovely shine to my lips. I didn’t find it was particularly buildable, but I don’t think the colors that I received were different enough from my natural lip color that I would notice buildability. I am planning on trying out a bolder color at Sephora next time I go there. The shine does transfer off easily when I’m eating or drinking, but it only gives me an excuse to whip out the pretty tube of lipstick again, so I’m ok with that.
Now the thing is that the price point of this lipstick is quite high – at CA$61.00 at Sephora. It’s a lovely splurge item, especially if you want to have a little bit of glamour to carry around on a daily basis. I’m curious to know more about the other colors, and intrigued to see if it’ll keep my lips hydrated through a Canadian winter. I am considering not just doing a six-month check-in, but also a one-year check-in to test this lipstick through winter.
A lovely lipstick that acts like a lip balm
The lipsticks I received came in fully recyclable cardboard boxes, while the tubes themselves seem to be completely made of plastic (can we bring back metallic lipstick tubes and just purchase the inside piece, please?) YSL does packaging really well; I have really enjoyed whipping these babies out. I feel like the ultimate glam gal and loving the feeling. The lipstick’s texture is borderline lip balm texture, and I’m totally here for it. It smells divine—like a juicy cold nectarine you’ve just bitten into (can you tell I am very eager for summer?) It hydrates amazingly well; I haven’t had to reach for my lip balm at all a single time this week. And I don’t get that weird taste at the back of my throat that I get with some lipsticks, thankfully. Goodness, I hate that taste so much.
Both colors I received from Butterly were close to my natural lip color. The Nude Lingerie gave my lips a pinkish hue, while the Nude Lavallière turned them a little darker, with both adding a lovely shine to my lips. I didn’t find it was particularly buildable, but I don’t think the colors that I received were different enough from my natural lip color that I would notice buildability. I am planning on trying out a bolder color at Sephora next time I go there. The shine does transfer off easily when I’m eating or drinking, but it only gives me an excuse to whip out the pretty tube of lipstick again, so I’m ok with that.
Now the thing is that the price point of this lipstick is quite high – at CA$61.00 at Sephora. It’s a lovely splurge item, especially if you want to have a little bit of glamour to carry around on a daily basis. I’m curious to know more about the other colors, and intrigued to see if it’ll keep my lips hydrated through a Canadian winter. I am considering not just doing a six-month check-in, but also a one-year check-in to test this lipstick through winter.
Beautiful shade for brown skin girls
This is such a beautiful lipstick. I love how it left my lips feeling soft and plump and this colour is just perfect. I was skeptical about it as I am a brown girl but it looked gorgeous on me and made me spring/summer ready
I love how it is enough, no need to put a gloss or multiple things as one lipstick is all you need to get the trendy lips!
Perfect treatment for lips!
This is such a beautiful lipstick. I love how it left my lips feeling soft and plump.
I love how it is enough, no need to put a gloss or multiple things as one lipstick is all you need to get the trendy lips!
The perfect colour!
This lipstick is so lovely! The colour is absolutely perfect. Not too intense and perfectly tinted. This lipstick goes on so easy and feels much more like a lip gloss. It's not sticky though. Feels like it hydrates and not dry out the lips. Also the container is so pretty!
Sparkle and Shine
This lipstick is so great. The container is stunning. It goes on light and feels like a gloss more than a lipstick. It's not sticky or dry. Provides moisture and shine! Has a a subtle sparkle to it as well! This colour has a slightly more orange undertone, so its best for people who prefer warmer colors.
A gorgeous cool toned pink
The formula of this Loveshine Lipstick is so nourishing and moisturizing. Not drying at all, and feels much more like a lip balm than a lipstick. 44 is a really pretty MLBB (my lips but better) shade, in a nice cool toned nude pink. Love the packaging as well, very luxe! These have a slight fruity scent to them as well.
A beautiful warm nude pink
I love the formula of this lipstick! It's somewhere between a lip balm and a lipstick which is perfect for people like me who typically avoid lipsticks due to how drying they can be. It's so nourishing and moisturizing, and surprisingly long-lasting too! 150 is a gorgeous warm nude-ish pink shade, with hints of red. It's really beautiful! I love the packaging too, so classy and feels very high quality.
Nourishing & Glowy Perfection!
there’s a reason why the loveshine line is so hyped and many shades are sold out - they are amazing! love how nourishing they are, the lip oil consistency is buttery soft and glides on without the sticky feeling you get from liquid lip oils or glosses!
the scent reminds me of a product i used when i was younger, i can’t quite remember what it was but it makes me nostalgic…
i tried the shades 44 Nude Lavalliere, a pretty nude pink, and 150 Nude Lingerie a warm nude pink with some shimmer, i’d say it’s a touch orange almost - i think it would be lovely for summer, whereas shade 44 is more of a winter colour for me!
the packaging is stunning, the lipsticks are quite heavy and i love when a luxury brand like YSL has that kind of packaging because it just feels more high-end! definitely a treat for mother’s day, a birthday or just to pamper yourself because these are fantastic!
Nourishing & Glowy Perfection
there’s a reason why the loveshine line is so hyped and many shades are sold out - they are amazing! love how nourishing they are, the lip oil consistency is buttery soft and glides on without the sticky feeling you get from liquid lip oils or glosses!
the scent reminds me of a product i used when i was younger, i can’t quite remember what it was but it makes me nostalgic…
i tried the shades 44 Nude Lavalliere, a pretty nude pink, and 150 Nude Lingerie a warm nude pink with some shimmer, i’d say it’s a touch orange almost - i think it would be lovely for summer, whereas shade 44 is more of a winter colour for me!
the packaging is stunning, the lipsticks are quite heavy and i love when a luxury brand like YSL has that kind of packaging because it just feels more high-end! definitely a treat for mother’s day, a birthday or just to pamper yourself because these are fantastic!
These reviews are the subjective opinions of ChickAdvisor members and not of ChickAdvisor Inc.