We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eye Liner - Prestige Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
141-160 of 200

Dior Eyeliner in Brown

3 reviews

Very sharp and precise application. Long wearing and smudge proof. Amazing quality and very underrated in the beauty world. I have used the black liner by Dior and it proves to be just as amazing
blinc Eyeliner Pencil - Black

1 review

So this is a $19 eyeliner, saw it on Joyus.com and decided to try it. OMG - it is AMAZING. Made in Germany and a bit pricey - but this stuff is the bomb. Esp for us girls who have a struggle making eyeliner look like natural. Not only can I put this on top and bottom in less...
Urban Decay Heavy Metal Glitter Eyeliner

20 reviews

I was already an UD fan but these glitter eyeliners are fantastic! They are quite pricey and I was shocked by the price at first, but I have 4 of the colours and you really don't need much. You can use simply as a liner (I do above another liner like solid black) OR you can...
stila cosmetics Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner in Damsel

5 reviews

I love this product! The best part is that it is a twist up. I hate sharpening my pencils. I feel like it is such a waste of product. This eyeliner is very easy to apply. The one thing I would change is decreasing the thickness of the stick so it is easier to apply a thiner...
sephora flashy eye liner

1 review

I love the wide range of colours this eye liner comes in. Goes on very easily, but needs a primer if you want it to stay on all day.
SEPHORA COLLECTION Long-Lasting 12HR Wear Eye Liner

3 reviews

By far my favourite eyeliner!! I love that this liner dries matte, dries quickly, and glides on easily. The applicator is so easy to use and sorta help with making those beautiful wings. It glides on easy, even on glitter eyeshadows properly. The precision of the tip is on...
Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyes

21 reviews

If your are looking for an eyeliner that is smudge proof and water proof you've come to the right place! I use this eyeliner if I now it will be super hot and humid outside so that I know it will stay on. I also have worn it to the pool and have come home to see that my eyeliner...
Make Up For Ever Aqua Liner

18 reviews

This eyeliner is just great it’s long lasting and waterproof plus doesn’t smudge at all and has a nice liquid Texture just love it u should try it once
Clinique Kohl Shaper For Eyes

2 reviews

Truth be told: I stole this one from my Mom's house. It's the Blackened Taupe shade and I found that it is the absolute perfect shade for my brows. I've never used a brow pencil before this one b/c all the colours were usually wrong; either too black or too reddy. This shade...
stila cosmetics Seeing Stars Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner Set

2 reviews

Hardly smudges, love the gray color, easy to use, glides right on, retractable, But Pricey, but I guess it's worth it.
Smashbox Limitless Liquid Liner Pen

7 reviews

About 10 years ago I decide to splurge on a good eyeliner. I went to shoppers drug mart ( which btw I'm so happy you can buy it at the drug store. Being in a small town to far from sephora and all). And the saw the liquide liner and thought I would give it a try. Needless to say...
Benefit Cosmetics Eye Bright Pencil

17 reviews

My make up bag is not complete without this eyeliner/highlighter. Its absolutely brilliant. It's the final product I add before mascara and setting spray. It does exactly what it says on the tin. Brightens eyes. I don't think I've used anything different since my teens.....its...
Smashbox Eye Beam

1 review

Smashbox Eye Beam is really fun. It is double-ended with this creamy, light iridescent magic stuff. The thick end is a highlighter and I use the narrow end on the inner corner of my eyes or to rim the inside line if I look tired. Salvation!
Sephora Nano Eye Pencil

1 review

These short eye pencils are very highly pigmented so only one sweep of the pencil is all you'll need. The metallic Nano pencils are among the best I've seen: the gold and silver are staples in my make-up bag, I use the silver ever day on the inside half of my eyes to give them...
stila cosmetics Eye Kajal

3 reviews

This is my absolute favorite eyeliner for the waterline. I have the color "tiger's eye" and I'm not sure what's so special about it, it's just the perfect color. Normally, liner on the waterline makes my light brown eyes looks small and beady. But this color really makes my eyes...
Clinique Quickliner for Eyes

12 reviews

The dark chocolate color is my favorite. It goes on smoothly and stays on well. However, the coffee color is extremely difficult to put on and barely shows up.
Marc Jacobs Magic Marc'er Precision Pen

2 reviews

This is a felt tip liner and it's very hard to get a precision line with this I hate it
stila cosmetics Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner in Turquoise

2 reviews

I would recommend this liner for lining your waterline because it is waterproof and it really does have great staying power. I did find myself having to reapply to get more colour and pigment but compared to other liners, it does last a very long time, especially on the...
Clinique Cream Eye Liner

2 reviews

This is well worth my money. One pencil lasts me over a year and I use it on a daily basis. Great colour choices and really seems to stay on my lash line but still washes off easily.
Lancôme Paris Eye Liner

2 reviews

One coat on my water line is enough, I don't have to go over it to increase the darkness. It goes on black, and lasts a long time without fading. I used it during a day out and 6hrs later it was still going strong. Very smooth, and easy to apply.