We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eyeliner Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
61-80 of 902

L'Oréal Paris Infallible Never Fail Eyeliner

23 reviews

This eyeliner I use just about daily an it has never failed me ! It goes on easy and makes the perfect winged look .. I've tried several eyeliners and this one is great highly reccomend
Maybeline Stiletto Eyeliner

1 review

I picked this up to try since it was on sale at Shoppers for about $8 I believe. Definitely the most dramatic liquid liner in how it shows up that I have ever tried and love that!! I gave it 4 stars for two reasons 1) it does get a little crumbly/cakey on me when it dries and 2)...
Tarte Sex Kitten Liquid Eyeliner

21 reviews

This is my favorite eyeliner by far! I've received a few in mystery makeup boxes but this one worked the best out of them all. I've continued to buy this eyeliner, especially when it's bogo on the Tarte site. The color is strong, no fading, and it doesn't smudge at all.
LimeLife by Alcone Perfect Eye Liner (Liquid)

3 reviews

This eyeliner pen is a game changer! I was always so scared to add a liquid liner to my makeup looks because I couldn't get it right! When I tried Limelife's perfect eyeliner pen I was amazed. The felt tip is so fine and soft it made making a perfect line so easy! It still takes...
Lise Watier Black Ink Liquid Liner

1 review

Over the years I've tried so many liquid eyeliners from high end brands and I find they always fade throughout the day. They don't stay super black. I didn't have this problem a decade ago, and I wonder if recipes are changing. Anyways - along comes this eyeliner which stays...
L'oreal Le Liner Signature

1 review

I love the product it looks very classy. It is smooth and very easy to apply, lasts for long time. price is very reasonable, you just need to scroll to have more No need to use pencil sharpener.
E.l.f Eyeliner Pen

1 review

This eyeliner pen is extremely affordable and works great. It is honestly comparable to high end/expensive eyeliner pen’s from Sephora. It’s a nice dark black colour, it goes on so smoothly, does not transfer or fade throughout the day. It’s waterproof and has a nice thin...
L'Oréal Le Liner Signature- Noir Cashmere

1 review

I was very pleasantly surprised by this eyeliner. I have been wearing liquid black eyeliner for a while, as I found that mechanical black liners smudged too much or looked too dull. While not a very deep black, the Cashmere 735 Le Liner Signature stayed put even on my non-primed...
Age Perfect Satin Glide Eyeliner

1 review

Being in my early fifties I am struggling with finding makeup for my face.My skin has changed so much and the makeup I used to wear I cant anymore. Im so thrilled with L'Oreal bringing out this age perfect collection for mature skin.The thing I was struggling with the most is...
wet and wild eyeliner

1 review

For the price it is one of the best liners out there. Its a little difficult to apply if you're new to eyeliner but once you get better the product is amazing and stays on for a while.
Maybelline Tattoo Studio Ink Liner

1 review

I love this product. It's a solid like of black across my eye lid. The applicator is easy to use, glides very well. I'm very impressed. If you're a liquid eye liner type of gal this is your jam
Milani the tank

1 review

This product I got to receive it. And let me say what it promotes is no lie. I end up rubbing my eyes when running errands and no smudges which I was shocked. Because I had some eyeliners saying they are waterproof but not actually working. Than at night I ran 1 1/2 and exercise...
L'Oréal le liner signature retractable eyeliner

1 review

This eyeliner is very convenient in that it doesn't require additional tools like sharpeners. You can just twist the lower part in either direction to extend or retract the pigment stick 'lead' inside. I got the shade Blue Jersey which is a dark, denim/navy blue shade. This...
Maybelline Tattoo Pencil Liner

1 review

I am pleasantly surprised work the tattoo eyeliner line by Maybelline. I purchased a couple colors (turquoise , purple and navy blue). The stay power is amazing! It lasts all day, didn't smudge and was super soft to apply. It's also super easy to remove with makeup remover! No...
hula beauty eyeliner

1 review

When I got this I was very excited I heard too many great things about the double sided eyeliner from hula beauty. I love the pencil not long wear but its really good, the liquid eyeliner side the brush was way to thick for me personally but when I say this was long lasting it...
Annabella waterproof liquid eyeliner

1 review

Just got my new Annabella blue spark eyeliner , wanted to try a blue colored eyeliner on my eyes. It might not be a high end eyeliner and has a beautiful blue color.Its hydrofuge hense liquid based. I had to give it a double coat after the first layer dried for a perfect blue...
LimeLife by Alcone Enduring Eye Liner Pencil

1 review

When a friend began selling LimeLife by Alcone, I was intrigued by the price point and that they boast "Leaping Bunny Certified" cosmetics (I prefer natural cosmetics). This eye liner lives up to it's claims, it is enduring!! I purchased this in Black and swiped it along my...
It Cosmetics Superhero Eyeliner No Tug in Mystic Emerald

1 review

Gotta werk it with the It Cosmetics No Tug Eyeliner! Easy to use, easy to make a sexy wing look. I usually have to hold and stretch my eyelid to get my eyeliner precise, but with this product I had no issues applying it without pulling my lid. The color is gorgeous and makes...
Bourjois Liner Feutre Eyeliner

1 review

I have finally found the best liquid eyeliner, after trying lots of different brands, I find this one to be best the best. It's so easy to apply and is almost like a fine felt tip pen, so easy to control the lines, the colour doesn't fade throughout the day like some other...
Elf H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen

1 review

I bought this eyeliner after hearing a recommendation from a beauty influencer, and she was right! Worth every penny! Not the greatest eyeliner pen I've tried, but definitely the best for the price point. It's my favourite drugstore eyeliner pen. The tip is flexible felt and not...