We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eyeliner Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
101-120 of 902

Benifit eyeliner

1 review

The black eyeliner from benifit is a pen if you want long lasting straight lines it’s amazinng if you want the cheaper one they do a mini for £10 suitable for hand bag If you sweat it’s not the best one it smudges a bit
Stargazer uv eyeliner

2 reviews

Easy to use ...soft.. so it goes exactly where you want it to. Dab a bit of color stay eye shadow over the top and I guarantee it will stay until you remove it!...thank you ...love all colors ...was.. exited to try all of this amazing colors...
Avon true colour glimmerstick

1 review

Lovely selection of colours to suit. Pencil not to hard not too soft. Easy to apply and stays put for ages. Available in a range of colours to suit all make up occasions. Perfect addition to your make up case
N.Y.C Eyeliner Duet - Mockingbird/Black

2 reviews

Was a great product for the price I will definitely be going back to by another what else can you expect from NYC a ways. Was easy to apply only thing was hard to get off but it's Eyeliner so that's normal
L'Oréal Paris Infallible Lacquer Eyeliner, Blackest Black

1 review

This is the best eyeliner I have ever used. I have used it everyday for almost two years now. The product is very pigmented and lasts all day! As well, it is cry proof which is very important for me. Over the last two years the product has not dried out at all and it only cost...
L’oreal flash cat eye

2 reviews

This product is very easy to apply. It comes with a stencil that gives you an even accurate look. I love how dark it is and how long it lasted throughout the day without smudging. You can easily apply in the morning and continue to wear all night without having to reapply...
Lancome monsieur big marker

1 review

This is a very simple eye liner marker to use, big and bold made easy. It glides across the eye line effortlessly with the intense black pigment, ensures a clean defined line. The tip is accurate and soft, smooth, no smudging, and waterproof, but is still easy to remove. Great...
REVLON So Fierce Vinyl Eye Liner Pencils

1 review

Those insta-worthy highly pigmented angel wings can be yours in a slick swipe of the new So Fierce Vinyl Eyeliner pencils. Even though it’s a pencil, this liner glides on glossy, HD colour as if it’s a gel or liquid eyeliner and is just as easy and precise, with Revlon’s...
Avon Glimmerstick Blackest Black Eyeliner

1 review

A hidden gem in one of beauty's slightly forgotten brands, Avon. I've been using Avon's 'Blackest Black' Glimmerstick Eyeliner pencils for about two years now and they are one of the best budget eyeliner substitutes that I have ever come across. 7am: Top lid eyeliner applied...
Covergirl just gimmie noir gel pot eyeliner

1 review

I was excited to try this product out.But that was very short lived.Maybe I'm not applying it right,but I have tried to play around with it but it is not for me.It wasn't smooth like I thought it would be and so it was very hard to try and apply it on to my eyes with a nice thin...
e.l.f. Cosmetics Essentials Liquid Eye Liner

50 reviews

Didn't care for this product. I found that the brush picks you quite a bit of product making it near impossible to have a nice fine line without some blowouts. I also found the brush too long and flimsy and difficult to use. Great price but terrible design.
Langmanni - Glitter Heavy Metal Eyeliner

1 review

This stuff is awesome and super cheap. I paid under $2.00 for this stuff on Ebay. Sometimes beauty products on there are a hit or mess so you have to be careful but that's why I try and post reviews about the ones I try. This stuff is wicked and if you apply two layers of it...
e.l.f. Cosmetics Waterproof Eyeliner Pen

23 reviews

This is my go to eyeliner. I am not the best at using eyeliner and dont use it as often but this one is easy application and gets the job done. Its also super affordable
L'oreal infallible cat eye waterproof  eyeliner

1 review

I love this product it has a nice wide tip and you only have to apply it once they also provide a applicator for perfect cat eye. I can put this on in the morning and it lasts into the evening no need to reapply. I also love that it is waterproof. I would recommend this product...
L'Oréal Paris Matte Signature Eyeliner

2 reviews

hi 👋 i have been using this product since one yaer all can say is it amazing and very easy to apply and it does not cause spreadness of eyliner it also has a brush which allows it to apply eyliner in very easy way.
Burt's Bees Defining Retractable Eyeliner

5 reviews

I recieved the eyeliner in the shade onyx. I liked the packaging of this product and looked good when I opened it. I applied it to my eyes and it took a few times for it to apply but the moment I closed my eyes it wash away. It wouldn't last very long but it was a nice color...
Burt's Bees Nourishing Eyeliner

9 reviews

Is this the best clean eyeliner there is? No. But it’s a good bang for your buck comes in more than one shade and is easy to use. Sharpens well and can often find on sale
Bang beauty felt tip eyeliner black

1 review

I really like using this felt tip pen liquid eyeliner by bang beauty. It has a very thin tip/ eye pen it really helps me apply it as I am new to applying eyeliner. Very nice packaging and very easy to use. This does not smudge/ budge once it’s dry. Very reasonably priced too.
Revlon So Fierce Vinyl Eyeliner, Midnight Mystery, 0.042 Ounce

1 review

I really love this eyeliner. It is a smooth-gliding waterproof gel pencil eyeliner that creates a shiny, vinyl finish. It goes on so smooth, nothing like a pencil normally does. The application is precise because it goes on so smooth. This is a 16 hour, waterproof eyeliner. I...
essence smokey 2 in 1 khol liner

1 review

I don't use a lot of liner but I purchased this because I was looking for a simple and quick alternative for a smokey eye. This does the job, I use a tiny bit on my upper lip, smudge it into lash line and bring up into the crease slightly. There is enough product left on brush...