We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eyeliner Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
161-180 of 902

Revlon ColorStay 2 in 1 Angled Kajal Eyeliner

1 review

Revlon ColorStay 2 in 1 Angled Kajal Eyeliner is one of the best eyeliners that I have ever used. This eyeliner is waterproof, has an angled tip for easy application and a smudge brush if wanted to achieve a smokey eye look. The eye liner is soft and smooth, feels nice when...
Eyeco eyeliner

2 reviews

I solely use liquid pen eye liner.. After trying the Black magic liner I will never buy another brand again. It does not budge and has eyelash groth serum built in the product not to mention it is an actual brush not a felt tip. I have not seen a brush tip other than on a Dior...
Eyeliner Stencil

3 reviews

This product was so helpful in my everyday makeup routine. Everyone should have one. Highly recommend and I will be purchasing more of this product in the future..
Lavender shimmer NYX eye pencil

1 review

When I first saw this lavender shimmer eye pencil at the NYX store, I thought the shine of it looked amazing! Once I got home & put it on my lids, it was way too light but the shimmer was showing on my lids more than the lavender shade, as well as under my eyes & all over my...
Kate V D tatoo liner

1 review

While I will probably always never be 100% with how I apply liquid eyeliner, I am happy enough with this product. Stays on quite well with ALL eyelid primers I have tried. The black is a beautiful color, dries quicker than a blink, and brush applicator is fairly user-friendly. T
Pretty vulgar gel ink liner

8 reviews

I REALLY wanted to love this. The packaging is so cute but this eyeliner just NEVER dries down. I looked like a mess. I tried applying shadow on the line after application to set it but that didn’t help much
L’Oréal Paris Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner

6 reviews

I started using L’Oreal’s Infallible eyeliner because I didn’t want to pay $26+ for my Urban Decay liner. This works even better than UD! It stays on all day, goes on smooth and is still easy to remove. The dark brown is great for my fair skin and the pencil lasts a long...
Maybelline Eyestudio Lasting Drama Waterproof Gel Pencil

2 reviews

I bought this Maybelline waterproof gel eye pencil in the shade Lustrous Sapphire. I purchased it on sale at Real Canadian Superstore for $2.75 which is an amazing price for such a great high intensity colored eyeliner. It makes my chestnut brown eyes pop! This gel pencil glides...
Milk makeup long wear gel eyeliner

2 reviews

It's so hard to find a perfect eyeliner. Eather the pencil is to dry or the liquid eyeliner is too runny or way to think. I found this one just right. Also your able to layers with smudging it all over your eyes.
Sephora Nano Eye Pencil in Iced Brown

1 review

I decided to buy my first sort of high end makeup product at Sephora when I got my Christmas money a while ago. I decided on an eyeliner pencil since I tend to wear eye liner on a regular basis. The nano versions are great for travelling or if you want to try out the colour...
Essence waterproof gel liner

1 review

$4 for a product that I put on my face, went to bed, woke up and was still in place, you bet your money I’ll recommend this long lasting pigmented gel liner, not only that, it is waterproof but still dosnt pull your leg to take it off, I use it everyday!!
Colormates eyeliner pencil-black

1 review

I absolutely love this eye liner. I can apply it in the morning and wear it all day with minimal to no smudging. It glides on smooth Everytime and is easily removable at the end of the day!
Doucce smudge resistant eyeliner

1 review

I hadn't tried any products from this brand previously but their first impression unfortunately wasn't a great one for me. I gave this eyeliner a try without using any kind of primer on the lid first since it was supposedly smudge resistant. Not the case for me - it honestly...
ELF Liquid eyeliner

11 reviews

It is not water proof. It does not last long and comes off very easy and quickly . It does not dry quickly. I started applying the outline and tried to fill in but it pulled out/wiped out the application.
Touch In Sol Style Sepia French Garden Gel-Liner With Diamond

1 review

Decent eyeliner. Goes well on my waterline and doesn't fade. I have the shade "Jardin". It's dark brown with green sparkles, although i don't really see any sparkles when applying..I only see the sparkles on the pencil tip itself which is a little disappointing. All in all, it's...
Annabelle eyeliner khol duo taupe

1 review

I will buy this product again. I like that there is two colors to pick from. I use the darker to liner on the top and the lighter brown for the bottom or even my eyebrows if I am stuck.
Maybelline Eye Studio Eyeliner in Brown

22 reviews

I have squinty eyes and most eyeliners smear all under my eyes but I find this doesn't. It is the best for my eyes and I love it so much use black and blue also.
SEPHORA COLLECTION Colorful Waterproof Eyeliner 24 HR Wear

7 reviews

I absolutely love this long lasting liner from Sephora. Not only is it affordable but it is very high end and provides long lasting and dramatic results. It’s definitely one of my favourite products.
NYX VIVID BRIGHTS EYELINER

6 reviews

I'm not sure why these eyeliners get only 3.5 stars, they are excellent. Normally, I mix up my own colored eyeliners, however, these are such a time saver. They glide on smooth (with the acceptation of the green, it's a bit fussy) and they last all day, like ALLL day. Provided...
Annabelle khol eyeliner black

1 review

The annabelle eyeliner black color is really nice and is easy to use to outline your eye with perfect curves. Its a bit small but the price isn't high so its fine.