Takes forever to dry and smudges SO easily.

I got this in a subscription box. I have their banana powder and really like it but I was so disappointed in the waterproof mascara. It takes forever to dry and smudges everywhere, it gets all over my eyelids. And then, it's not even waterproof - I have tried every possible waterproof mascara and this stuff definitely is NOT. I had terrible raccoon eyes after 2 hours.