This was the second ice cream I reviewed. I had to go to a couple of stores to find it - and actually was not looking forward to a banana flavored ice cream - especially investing $9 when i can just add a banana.
Well was I surprised!.. I do get the impression that Breyers is heading toward a luxury/ gourmet product. They achieve it with this product.
The unexpected crunch of the the graham crackers in contrast with the mild banana flavor impressed me. I would serve it accompanying the dark chocolate on a platter with some strawberries and perhaps with a side of some hot caramel.
YUMMY!
oh and i have to mention, that visually i like the way the ice cream looks.. just adds even more to the "gourmet" appeal.

After I got my wonderful package from Breyers through the product review club, I had to think of the perfect place to try these flavors.... I took them to a friends summer bbq and the banana cream pie flavor was a hit! I don't think there are too many banana ice cream options on the market and this one (like all breyers double churn ice creams) was creamy and tasty, without a fake banana taste. It tasted like creamy banana and I loved the graham cracker pieces.... The only disadvantage was the price. I usually buy breyers when it's on sale because regular price, this ice cream is $9/carton (usually goes on sale for $4.99). I would buy it again (when it's on sale). My husband who loves banana desserts especially loved it and it was also popular with the kids at the party!

This was the second flavour that I tried out of the three and it was one that I was pretty excited for. I thought the ice cream flavour itself was really, really good. I didn't find it too rich and loved the mix of the grahm flavour throughout each bite. And I really liked how it wasn't grahm pieces it was kind of like a ribbon so you pretty much taste it with every spoonfull. I didn't find it as creamy as the cheesecake flavour, but you could really taste the banana, which I thought was really good because I think that when trying to bring out fruit flavours in ice cream it can really be a hit or miss.
Overall, I found it enjoyable. We ate it for dessert one night and everyone seemed to really like it and even asked for seconds :)

A huge thanks to Chick Advisor! Loved the kit.

I have to say that this was my favourite out of the three flavours I tried, and that means a lot because i HATE banana. The banana flavour is very mild and blends nicely with the cream flavour and graham crumb swirls. I really liked that they graham part of the ice cream still had a bit of crunch and was not completely smooth and added an extra texture to the creamy ice cream. I also liked that the ice cream as a whole was not sickeningly sweet as some other "dessert" flavour ice cream is.

I would definatly buy this ice cream again (even at the $6.99 price) and definitely recommend it.

First of all, I was very impressed with the package that arrived from Breyers. It was a really lovely gesture for them to send 3 little ice cream bowls and spoons.

Since I'm lacking in freezer space I decided to throw an ice cream party so my friends could help me test out the 3 ice cream flavours.

I have to say, this flavour was the least desired by my friends out of the three that we tested. The flavour was better than we expected, although not everyone was sold on the idea of banana cream pie ice cream. I don't think that this will become a best seller, but it's certainly an option when you want something different!

We all felt that $8 was a bit much for the tub of ice cream, and more than once people remarked "what's with the double churn thing?" It seemed to raise people's expectations for the quality of ice cream, and while it was quite creamy, it didn't seem all that different from other ice cream we've eaten.

I tested this product through the review club. Or atleast I tasted it two or three times.

Honestly, I didn't really like this ice cream. I've tried banana flavoured popsicles before, but not ice cream. I was curious to try it, but I must say I was disappointed.

What I liked: The banana flavour was alright. It really did taste like I was eating a fresh banana, but it was so creamy and the taste was a bit too strong.

What I didn't like: I really didn't like the waffer or what ever the crunchy substance was. I found it made the ice cream feel gritty. Along with the other two ice creams (Dark Chocolate Velvet and Chocolate Cheesec Cake) the ice cream melted really fast.

All in all, I wouldn't really recommend this ice cream except for the use in smoothies. My brother didn't mind the ice cream, so I suggested he try it in a smoothie and he seemed to like it. Other than that though, for the price that it is, honestly, I would just walk on by.

I have to admit I was leery to try this because banana cream pie is my favorite pie. But I was not disappointed! The banana flavor was not overpowering and this ice cream did the trick :) I found the texture a little weird at first, but got used to it after a few bites and realizing that it was meant to be like the pie crust. I'll likely buy it again, but definitely not as often as the chocolate!

I don't really like bananas (or even most banana-flavoured things), but I have to say, I was pleasantly surprised by this ice cream. I kind of thought that it would end up being more 'for guests', but I've eaten almost all of it myself in the end. What I like best is that the banana flavour is 'authentic', and does not have that 'manufactured banana' flavour (you know what I'm talking about!). Having said that, however, it's not overpowering, which I think is part of the reason that I - as a non-banana-lover in general - am really enjoying this ice cream. The nice light/mild banana flavour is quite refreshing for summer. And the good flavour is paired with a really nice texture (true to other Breyers Double Churned ice creams) that's wonderful on the tongue - absolutely no ice crystals or 'graininess' to this one. I would recommend it (and have already done so) for sure - even to someone who doesn't think she likes bananas!

Hmmm.... this is very yummy. Rich and creamy. The banana flavour is really good, not a fake banana flavour - tastes like the real thing. I really like the chunks of pie crust in it too.

i was so excited to try this as i love anything banana, at first scoop you can tell its very very creamy
it tasted like it was suppose too the pie part was interesting it tasted like a mixture of graham cracker and brown sugar i did find it to be a little too grainy especialy when you got a big chunk of it in your mouth,
the ice cream was very fluffy but it was more heavy on the cream side than banana which dissapointed me a little as i was looking forward to the banana part of it all would i reccomend it..... yes but if your expecting it to taste like banana then no.