I have only tried the gold black I believe and I love it, it makes my hazels eyes pop. I also find it doesn't clump which is a huge bonus to me. It would take a lot to make me switch mascaras

Love their whole Exact eye brightening line. It makes your eye colour pop and i find it doesnt clump which is a problem I have with most mascaras

I Love the blue tint to the Black Sapphire mascara. The wand makes it easy to avoid clumping. I have tried many other kinds, but keep going back to this one. Worth every penny.

I really liked this mascara when I first put it on, but its also really flaky. The flakiness has to do with the shimmer that is in the formula of this mascara. The wand is great though, it volumizes and separates.

I love this product. It is cheaper in the US than in Canada though. I have bought other brands on sale and regretted it. I always go back. The product doesn't clump, it lengthens and brightens. It is the only makeup product I wear daily.

One of the best ones for the price

Love it!! makes my brown eyes POP! haven't had any clumping issues. and as far as other mascara's go i'd say the price is about right.

Love covergirl, however since i have really dark eyes, I don't think it made much of a diff to me.

I have tried the gold black and I am really impressed with the way it wears. When you are getting to the end of it it tends to clump a bit more. I would recommend this product..

I can see how this mascara would be fantastic for light eyes, but I have black eyes, and it just made me look funny. The quality of the mascara itself is amazing, especially considering the price. If you are dark skinned with dark eyes, go for something else though!