Not my favourite

I have bought this and used it. At first I thought it was good until it started to rub off. I’m not a huge fan of the wand. Now I do like cover girl products but this mascara was definitely not my favourite.

Love love love it

My favourite cheaper mascara by far never clumps or dries out my eyes. Love that it doesn’t smudge or flake as well. I also like that you can find it at plenty of places as well

its okay

i've used this on and off for years and bought a double pack of them not long ago. i really like the wand and how it applies on, however i found that it rubs off around my eyes and doesnt last. maybe they changed the formula?

Beautiful final result

Applying a thin coat does justice, but if you like a thick look like me, it works great for think layers. it makes your eyelashes look beautiful and not clunky like most mascaras. great for a night out or a night in.

Great mascara I would buy this product again

I like the lightness and felt on my eyelashes the length of give to the lashes is phenomenal non-clumping brush makes it easy for applying. I must try for those great volume light eyes

Nice Mascara

For a drugstore brand this mascara works really well. I love how it curls, it lasts long enough and doesn't smudge once you apply it properly.
I've always been a fan of the Covergirl brand and this mascara is no exception.

This is one of the best mascaras

This was one of the nicest mascaras I have ever used. It was long lasting. I had it on for more than 24 hours. I would definitely recommend this mascara to anytone. I will buy this in future as well.

I love this product from covergirl for my lashes!

I love this product from covergirl! It does the job and it doesn't make my eyes itchy like other products I have tried in the past. It gives me the boost I need.

Good for a Value Mascara

I have been using this mascara for years as my "value" go-to mascara. I have other mascaras that are higher-end and for different purposes (ex. evening out) but this one is good for daily use and a natural look.

I have seen reviewers mention clumping and I find that this tends to happen when the product sat on the shelf too long at the retailer. When this happens I add a 1/2 drop of food-grade lavender essential oil directly to it and it solves the issue. Oddly enough I also seem to find the "Brown-black" shade lighter in consistency and smoother on application then the all-black shades.

Application: I am always careful when applying mascara and I do follow a specific technique so unless this is very dried out when I purchase it then I don't have issues with clumping. I have also used this for layering under more pigmented glam mascaras (think cobalt blue or bright purple) and it worked well. I have sensitive eyes (ocular rosacea) and it doesn't cause me irritation and removes easily with eye wipes.

Effectiveness: I use the regular version (waterproof mascara of any brand irritates my eyes) and unless I use a heavy moisturizer or sweat excessively then it stays put. I have naturally long eyelashes and this mascara defines them and plumps them up in a natural-looking way making it good for daily use. I only apply one layer and I don't use a primer or any type of glue-on lash extensions. I have used magnetic lash extensions with this mascara and it was worked great.

Shade selection: I had tried several shades and liked them all. My only con is that previously this mascara was available in a navy blue shade and it was stunning on blue eyes. I have not seen it for a few years now and wish it would be brought back as I have a hard time finding a blue mascara I really like.

Overall for the price and availability (I live in a Northern area that can make it difficult to obtain a lot of product brands) I like this mascara and have yet to find a better value-based option.

This mascara is not for me.

I'va used this mascara in the past, at the beginning it when on smoothly and clump free but product dries up and become clumpy in bottle just after a few use..if the formula didn't dried up so fast in bottle it would have made a great product.