I get the one in waterproof since that is the only type of mascara that will hold my curled lashes.

Pros:
Great volume.
Decent length.
Great on separation.

Cons:
Flakes a bit by the end of the day.
Wand is quite large so it's a little harder to apply on the lower lashes.
Smells weird the more you use it.

Final verdict: I've repurchased this a few times and its not a disappointing mascara.

I do like this mascara, but its not one that I would buy all the time. I do like that it does what it says it does, which is volume!

This is my favourite mascara!! I've tried so many different ones (even a $30 one) and nothing compares to this classic.

Cover girl is a great brand.. love this mascara .ni clumping and did not smudge

CoverGirl Mascara in Blackest Black;

great mascara in between higher end mascara makeup brands and also when on a budget

i found it works
did its work gave length, separated, and volume

easy and comfortable brush

black color was good stayed put on eye lashes

I personally just wish cover girl changed up their tube packaging and colors, that's just me

I'm not a huge fan of drugstore mascaras but when I don't feel like shelling out $30 for my beloved Too Faced Better Than Sex mascara this is the one I turn to. It's not perfect but it does the trick, good color, thickens your lashes and doesn't clump.

It is one of my favourite mascaras. I'm not a fan of the clumpy-spider leg look, and this mascara does not do that.

I always seem to make the choice to pick covergirl mascara above other brands even though I've never gotten amazing results from their brand

It's a big brush but the bristles are very thin so it's able to get more lashes and make them fuller and longer. It's a basic staple.

Love it, my go to mascara. Makes my lashes personally look so full and long.