E.l.f eyeliner didn't stay on very long

I recently purchased this at a gr8 value thinking I was getting a bargain BUT disappointed it had worn off within a few hours. As the saying goes, you get what you pay for!! I love the color coffee that I purchased, just right for my green eyes.

Gorgeous!!!

I love this eyeliner and it is one of my favourites. I don't fee like it is sticky on the eyes and it lasts quite a long time. I would honestly buy it again and the price is very reasonable.

Inexpensive and easy to use!

I love this eyeliner. Rolls on easy and the colour looks great! The pencil form makes it easy to use and allows more control. I would buy this product again for its ease of use and its cost.

Full stars!

I couldn’t find my regular eyeliner in the store so I decided to save some money and buy this super cheap liner and I’m actually impressed!

Usually I pay upwards of $20 for a decent liner and I spent under $4 for this one and it’s doing the job.

It lasts all day and goes on easy. You have to have a steady hand to get the best out of this application (and I do). For under $4 I was surprised at the ease, colour, and lasting power of this liner!

Best liquid liner!

The e.l.f waterproof felt tip eye liner pen is amazing! I have oily kids and it's the only one I have found that absolutely doesn't transfer to my upper lid! #AMAZING

For me, this sucked. It wouldn't go on in a smooth black line, it was a patchy grey mess. It would flake off during the day no matter what I put under it (tried putting it on bare lids, over eye primer, over eyeshadow, etc). Even though this is super cheap, I wouldn't recommend wasting your money.

Personnellement, j'aime beaucoup le eyeliner de la marque Elf! Le pinceau est très fin ce qui permet de faire une belle ligne sans en mettre partout! Le produit sèche plutôt rapidement sur la paupière donc il n'y a pas de transfert sur le haut de la paupière! Aussi, quand je le met le matin, il est toujours bien en place à la fin de la journée!

Je n'ai vraiment rien de négatif à dire sur ce produit en plus du fait que son prix soit vraiment très bas! C'est un de mes produits Elf préféré!

I'm surprised of the negative/dry reviews about this, b/c mine is great. I've had this one kicking around unused for a while and just last week my regular liquid liner started drying out and not giving the perfect edge. So I was glad I had this for backup. My tube isn't dry at all. It has a much smaller and more precise brush tip than other brands, but the liquid is a good consistency and gives a solid liquid line without any fraying at the edges. Definitely good enough for me as the name brands. I bought this one out at the cottage after forgetting mine at home and is a steal and does the job perfectly.

I was really excited to give this a try because it was super cheap and looked amazing.

Sadly, that was not the case. The applicator looks like it works really well, however, it is very messy and gets all over the place.

The formula itself also looks promising, however once applied is very chalky and comes off very easily. In addition, the formula is not very opaque, and that is something that I look for in a eyeliner.

Although the price is right, it is not worth it. Spend your money on something else if you want an eyeliner that is going to make sharp lines, and last all day.

This has to be the worst Eyeliner I have ever tried! Terrible .. dry looking when you apply it, uneven and simply a waste of money. I hated this one ...