We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eyeliner Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
1-20 of 902

Maybelline New York Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel Eye Liner

383 reviews

I’ve been using this eyeliner for years for everyday wear...good value for $...I usually purchase other brush applicators and make sure I clean applicators after every use.
MAC Cosmetics Fluidline

242 reviews

Fluidline from MAC is the original potted gel eyeliner you can use with a brush for freehand strokes. This is just excellent for the cat-flick / feline flick if used with a fine brush you can create all sorts of eye make-up detail and it comes in different shades. This pot...
NYX Professional Makeup 2-in-1 Liner & Lash Adhesive

165 reviews

Loved this NYX eyeliner pen as I am a fan of the pen style eyeliners for the top lash line because they are easy to work with when you want a precise, even line with a bit of a flick whilst being mess free, this also dries down to a long lasting and stay-put line that only...
L'Oréal Paris Infallible Super Slim 24H Liquid Eye Liner

163 reviews

It’s a good eyeliner with sharp and thin point but it doesn’t last 12 hours and it’s not waterproof. I wore it in the morning and an hour later put eyedrip and the eyeliner started to come off. I do not really recommend this product to someone who want a waterproof and...
Maybelline New York Line Stiletto Ultimate Precision Liquid Eyeliner

176 reviews

I absolutely would re purchase! I lobe this precision this pen gives to your eyeliner wing. I love how it is extremely pigmented! Price is fantastic as well and can’t go wrong with the purchase
AVON Glimmersticks Eyeliner

186 reviews

I use this every time I do my makeup as it is such a staple! It makes the eyes pop and look so good and I love the glittery aspect for nights out, would defo recommend!
Maybelline New York Eye Studio Master Precise Liquid Liner

145 reviews

I've been recommended to use this eye liner by one of my friend. It was awesome for few days byt started geting dry later. The applicator is easy and effective to use but the tip is hard to move as it is kind of rigid. But it helped me giving perfect wing and lasts all day...
NYX Jumbo Pencils

115 reviews

These chunky eye pencils are great ,I used shimmery colours for a bold eye look and black and white ones recently for a Halloween look glides on smooth but doesn't budge without a good waterproof makeup remover.i use Nivea
L'Oreal Lineur Intense Felt Tip Liquid Liner

114 reviews

I love my eyeliners. This one is great because of the pen like tip. Makes it easy to apply and get " fancy" with it. Long lasting. Doesnt get all flakey. Pretty decent price too.
Annabelle Cosmetics Kohl Eyeliner

98 reviews

These are affordable and high quality eye liners! They do live up to more high end liners, but at a fraction of the cost! I love the variety of colors as well!
physician formula Eye Booster™2-in-1 Lash Boosting Eyeliner + Serum

53 reviews

This is another holy grail item of mine! I’ve been using this eyeliner for years and I haven’t found anything that compares. The brush tip makes application extremely easy and allows for a clean flick when I’m winging my liner. The colour stays all day and I don’t have...
Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner

65 reviews

I love using this eyeliner, it is very soft and it goes on smoothly and it definitely stays on really long. This does not smudge for me at all and I love that about this eyeliner
ELF - Expert Liquid Liner - Jet Black

33 reviews

This is by far one of my favourite eyeliner products and I love that not only is it affordable but it is very high-quality. It has a great tip that allows more flexibility than other rigid eyeliner products. It is a little bit difficult to find here in Canada sometimes but check...
Obsidian Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

1 review

I received this as part of my #Ipsy order. I do t wear a lot of eyeliner, but this one I found super easy to apply. Good quality, and stay power…. Perhaps too much. I found it a little hard to wash off. Lol
Kat Von D Tattoo Liner

11 reviews

I was actually given this as a sample in a bag I ordered as a gift with purchase from Sephora. Sephora doesn’t usually disappoint! I was excited to get my Kat Von D liquid eyeliner. It lasts ALL day and doesn’t smudge. I was pleasantly surprised to see that this is truly an...
Revolution The Liner

1 review

I bought this as I wanted to create a flick and I didn’t have my favourite Benefit Roller Liner. This is a great alternative. I like that I can get really close to my upper lashes and that I can create a thin line or thick line depending on how I hold the pen. The ability...
Benefit Roller Eye Bright Highlighter Pencil

1 review

Having seen this on Instagram, I bought it from Benefits UK website. I had bought it before I was told that I shouldn’t wear anything in my waterline which I have tried, and my eyes were red and very sensitive. I apply it to the inner corner of my eye and had no problems. I...
Benefit Badgal Bang 24 hour Eye Pencil - Blue

1 review

I have in the past used coloured eyeliners but have always gone back to either black or brown. I liked but not love the They’re Real Eyeliner, I found I had issues with the green, blue and purple eyeliners. I wasted more on a sheet of tissue than I had put on my eye. They...
Lola Automatic Eye Pencil - Grey

1 review

I am on a mission to find a dark grey not charcoal eyeliner. I bought this in the hopes it would be but unfortunately it is more silver than grey and glittery/shimmery. I wanted matte finish as I feel personally that shimmery/glittery don’t suit this 43-year old’s wrinkly...
PYT Beauty Wingman Liquid Liner

1 review

The staying power is 🔥🔥🔥! I tried this on when my husband and I went out for some shopping errands. My dry eyes were excessively watering (literally crying) due to the dry winter air and this liner did not smudge at all! It lasted me all day without moving! It has a...