I found that, for the price, this mascara was pretty good! It did lengthen and add volume to my lashes, like it said on the tube. I did find the product to be slightly clumpy on the wand, and would have to brush it off. I usually would put on two coats, and to prevent clumping as a previous reviewer mentioned, I would move the wand back and forth on my lashes, to spread the product out. Overall, I can't complain since it's an inexpensive alternative!