I bought the waterproof version of this Mascara and for the first few times it was great!! No smudging. It is only a month old and now smudging occurs within the first half hour. Disaster!

I bought this mascara because I love L'Oreal and I figured I loved the Manga ones so I thought I'd try this out. I loved it the first time I tried it. It actually got all my lashes and my lashes are short so normally when I applied mascaras, it doesn't get to my inner corner lashes and my outer corners. But this mascara got all my lashes and it lengthens and doesn't clump. Overall I love it and the price isn't too pricy.

I liked the mascara, however, after so long it starts to flake off. I found it didn't stay long enough.

I love how my lashes just stand right out now, almost looks like I'm wearing false lashes :)
You gotta try it, In Midnight Black!

My lashes are short and thin was looking for a product that would make them look longer & thicker.I use mascara very day and I'm not into false eye lashes so after trying several other products I found this one. I couldn't believe how much longer and thicker my lashes were. I would highly recommend this product.

So I had to try this new Butterfly mascara and am happy I did. The mascara bottle itself is sleek and a click to open and close. It's nice to not have to twist so much just to get the brush out.

The wand shape does help get those lashes on the outter edges of our eyes and I also found my lashes looked longer. I was disappointed that my lashes didn't look full and if not careful, got clumpy, but appreciated the length nonetheless. I found it easily washed off as well (I did not buy waterproof).

I'd use this again.

I purchased this mascara about 2 months ago, and I really did not like it, first it does not give the Voluminous effect, also it has a very strong odor that stays on all day... I used it every day and I just couldn't handle the smell anymore, it smells like petroleum on your eyelashes. I have tried many different kinds of L'oreal mascaras as well other OTC brands and the odor has never been this strong. Other then that, it usually clumps up.

This is another great mascara by loreal. The wand and formula leave my lashes curled and uplifted. Highly recommend!

Amazing, I used to pay more fore the lancome mascara and this one is 1/3 of the price and works better. My lashes look fake with this mascara. Easy to apply, great price.

This is just ad good as my $25 They're Real, and with the $8 price tag a much better deal. The brush is so unique, it/creates length and volume without that spidery look and the consistency is perfect, not too thick or thin. This one knocks it out of the park