Must have

This is the best eye liner I have ever used and I've used many different liners. It is intense black and only comes off when I remove it other then that it literally stays on through rain sweat etc.

Hated it

I bought this because Marcelle is known for being an hypoallergenic brand and I have very sensitive eyes, and while it didn't seem to irritate my eyes the quality and effectiveness of the product has left me disappointed.

I think the double ended liner tips were a good idea, and I do like the thinner one as it does give you that sharp wing look, but the product was definitely not pitch-black as I like it to be but instead looked very watered down and sheer. I had to apply two coats of this to make it look decent, and it ended up sticking to my upper lid and smudging all over my eyeshadow throughout the day, not a very nice look.

Great!

I really like this product! It goes on very smooth and precise, with full colour so theres no need to constantly go over it to make sure its dark. I love how easy it is to make fine lines - it really makes my eyes stand out! It held very well throughout my long days and even stayed on through my workouts! It came off fairly easily with make-up remover, but lasted sometimes even through my long showers!

It is so hard to find a good eyeliner. This one is just GREAT! Not only is the application easy, but it also stays for a whole day without going everywhere and making me look like a racoon !

I bought this eye liner couple of weeks ago and its not worth at all. I doesn't come our properly, leaves blanks while applying and smudges quickly. Not happy with this at all. I bought this with high hopes as I'm a fan of Marcelle products but this was a big disappointment.

I've tried this eyeliner and I really like how it applies. It is super easy to make nice crisp lines that last all day. The eyeliner is on the pricey side but it is really worth the splurge because it lasts long and it is not an eyeliner that you constantly need to apply. I would buy this again in a heartbeat.

This liquid eyeliner pen comes with both a brush tip and a felt tip to allow you some flexibility. It's waterproof but does come off easily with makeup remover. I can easily wear this product all day without the eyeliner feeling dry/cracked. The line doesn't smudge - it continues to look fresh for hours. It's a great value at around $13 - definitely one of my favourite liquid eyeliners in this price-range.

The Marcelle double precision liquide eyliner pen waterproof 12h + hold smudge proof is the best eye liner I had. It's easy to apply even for the goofy one. I loooove the hold and it's easy to remove. PLUS! it's 100% perfume free and it's ophtalmologist tested.