I LOVE THIS MASCARA! I have already repurchased this a few times and will continue to do so. It gives great length and volume without looking clumpy -- all you could ask for in a mascara! It's very black and doesn't flake off.

I wasn't impressed with this mascara, but I'm very picky about my mascaras! As expensive as this drug store brand is...I'll stick with spending the few extra dollars and get my department store, this is one area where you get what you pay for makes a big difference, in. My opinion!

Used to use this mascara and it works well and gets the job done. Never clumped up. Had to apply in 2-3 layers to get it to stay on all day and be visible.

this product was not good in my opinion... I found it was clumpy, and no increased volume..not sure about others, it irritiated my eyes...

I always buy this product on sale and stock up! For the price and quality this mascara is my go to !

It's just okay. I found that it dried out fast and once you are halfway through the tube, it does get a bit clumpy.

This mascara is not too bad but definitely could find better. I just didn't find that it gave me nice and long beautiful lashes and I found it clumpy

MAYBELLINE NEW YORK COLOSSAL VOLUME;

Maybelline has either good mascara or bad ones....this one was bad.

Nothing I liked about this mascara.

Made my eye lashes very clump-like.
Less volume, more clump like.

Mascara did not last long, became old quickly.

Did not even like the wand and yellow packaging exterior

This was decent when it was new, but it got clumpy and sludgy

Made my lashes clumpy and it was hard to remove