Honestly, I hated this eye liner and I had a lot of hope for it. By the name and brand you'd think it would be amazing but the tip is very long and flimmsy and hard to create a sharp tip wing. It's also like a marker so it dries out (faster and faster it feels) each time I use it. I tried balding it different way ect but it was always dried before I was even done my eye. Honestly I love the brand and the whole idea the formula of eye line is what is the problem.

I have been searching for a liquid eyeliner that didn't hurt my eyes - I have sensitive skin. I feel like I have a sensitivity to everything - haha! But anyway, this was a long lasting eye liner that didn't bother my eyes! It glides on easy and lasts all day !!

This eyeliner is very affordable and does the job amazingly to get that perfect wing. It's very pigmented applies extremely easily. And has a long lasting stay. I love !!

I like many use alot of eyeliners, So when a friend told me about this one I was excited I got to try it. It was smooth glide on and didn't smudge at all. I found this one to actually do what it says and would highly recommend this liquid liner.

I do really like the shape of this liner where you hold it. It fits really nice in your hand and makes applying the liner easy to apply. I also like the shape of the tip of this liner. It makes it really easy to make a thin line or a thick line. You don't end up having to go over a line multiple times to make it thicker because you can create a thick line on first swipe. It's a really innovative shape so I will definitely give Maybelline mega props for that! The thing I don't like about this eyeliner is that it's not really black on the eyes. It looks black when you applying and I was thinking 'YES THIS IS AMAZING'. But, after about 10 minutes of it being on my eyes, the colour faded and I don't really like the look of that. When I use a black liquid liner, I want it to be black as can be and stay that way. The couple of times I used this I had to go over it with another black liquid liner. I can't really tell you if it lasts long or flakes because I had to go over it with another liner.

I like how easy this eyeliner is to apply and that it isn't messy. The thing I don't like is that it's kind of like a marker that needs a good shaking every now and then. I seem to run low on color before I'm done with lining my eye. Other than that it is pretty nice.

This eyeliner is very handy, it goes on smooth and looks great! Sometimes it can smudge but it depends on your skin type (my skin's oily so it sometimes smudges if I don't use a primer first), usually works well!

I really liked this product, I found it a bit pricey, but worth it if you lead a busy life style and want to make sure your eyebrows are "On Fleek" all day long. It stayed on nicely through my hectic daily grind and goes on smoothly.

This is by far my favorite liquid eyeliner! It applies so nicely and is easy to make thick or thin lines depending on the result you are trying to achieve.

This is the be all and end all of liquid liners and nobody will convince me of anything else! I’ve been using this bombshell of a liner for probably 8 years and it has never disappointed! This is the easiest liquid liner to apply that I’ve ever used, and the color lasts, you literally can’t get it off without some type of makeup remover which is great because you never need to re-apply! The tip of the pen-like liner is perfect for achieving precise lines, and girls I am one of those shakey hand type people, so if I can get a sharp line, anyone can!