I really liked this mascara. I liked the brush because its slightly triangular. narrow at the tip and wider at the base. It makes it really easy for me to get the outer corners of my lashes all the way to the base. I don't find it overly lengthening, but i like that it really makes my eyes pop and coat the lashes really well. I didn't have smudges or flakes. I would buy this again.

I usually gravitate towards Rimmel brand mascaras but after hearing everyone rave about this on the blogs I knew I had to give it a try. The only Maybelline mascara I have ever tried is Great Lash which has always been anything but "great" for me.

I loved the design and colour concept of the packaging. The brush intimidated me at first and I instantly thought "clump city" but the application was smooth and the colour was a good representation of brown/black. My lashes were definitely lengthened without looking scary and I had virtually no clumping (except for any coats beyond a third). My only negative feeling about the mascara is the overly chemical smell of the mascara which wrinkled my nose a bit. But in general the mascara delivered and then some and I will recommending it too all my makeup junkie friends.

I bough this mascara because i've been seeing it everywhere...on tv. magazine, forums etc... The price is great, it's a fraction of the price from my favorite mascara. I also love the packaging, very chic and sexy. When i first opened it and looked at the wand, my first thought is that the wand is a lot more sparse and thin than a lot of my other mascaras. I tried it on my top lashes and my lashes definitely looked longer. The only thing is that since my lashes are pin straight, the mascara didn't give my lashes a lift to show that length. I tried it on my bottom lashes and i loved the result. Since my bottom lashes doesn't need a lift, it really did a good job on lengthening my bottom lashes. It also does not clump as much. As for removing the mascara, i use a cleansing oil and it's a bit tough to get the mascara off. I have to rub it quite a bit. Overall, This mascara is great for my bottom lashes or lashes that doesn't need a lift of curl. I grab this mascara almost daily for my bottom lashes, but i wished it worked as well for my top lashes!

As a woman with short, sparse and virtually clear lashes, I am always on the lookout for a good mascara recommendation. I need the intersection of both length and volume, and I will pay almost any price for it frankly. My favorite, and the benchmark by which I measure all mascaras is Lancombe's Definicils. Lash Stiletto claims to give you extreme length, as well as shine and conditioning benefits. The mascara kind of "paints" on very wet - you need to apply very carefully, b/c lashes stick together easily because of the wetness. The directions advise you not to apply additional coats after it dries, and this is definittely good advice; the mascara starts to clump and get sticky if you try to apply it after it dries. However, if you comb it on very precisely while wet you do achieve an impressive length, and enough body to really look like you own a nice set of lashes. You have to know when to stop applying however, becasue the mascara feels kind of heavy and unnatural if you put on too much. I liked it enought to buy a second tube when I saw it on sale as a bogo with other Maybelline products, but it didnt beat out my Definicils either. However, it's nice to have the drug store option at a great price when I'm looking to save a few bucks, and I like to keep a few brands on hand in my cosmetics "war chest."

The first time I wore this mascara my friends said it looked like I wasn't wearing anything at all! I already have naturally long lashes so maybe that was the problem. But the brush isn't very good either. It looks like a skinny twig. I wouldn't recommend this. Not unless you're going for the REALLY natural look.

Pros: I already have pretty long eyelashes and this made my eyes "pop" even more.

Cons: I don't think they make a waterproof formula just yet. I unknowingly rub my eyes constantly so this definitely smeared on me.

This mascara is very good! When i bought it, i was looking for a mascara that would lengthen very much and this product delivers! My usual product application is 5 coats and with this my lashes look almost like in the commercial!

I am one of those that have really light lashes. This mascara was awesome. It gave my lashes the depth in color that I needed and loved. The best part is it gave me incredible lash length.

It does lenghten lashes, however I usually find myself standing in front of the mirror applying mascara for five minutes. If you need to re-apply later in the day, it all has to come off otherwise it ends up completely clumpy. I like how much lenght was added to my eyelashes however there are tonnes of mascaras out there that do the same thing without the added time and clumping.

I love this mascara! I thought it was going to be like the Define-A-Lash, but this separates each lash, lengthens them. I love it, no clumps at all. There isn't much volume, so I add one coat of LashBlast and then Lash Stiletto and the result is fabulous!