This mascara is by far the worst I have EVER tried, and believe me I have tried TONS! This stuff is junk! I don't understand the formula, it's supposed to be waterproof, ok, the texture feel like thick goopy honey on my eyes, I wasn't able to layer to get length, or to thicken. I am very disappointed in everything about this crap mascara, I believe I was duped into spending around $10ish on this, which is about $9.50 too much in my opinion! Honestly I'm not trying to be so harsh but it took me almost 45 minutes and a whole bottle of my micellar water to get this gunk off my eyes, which btw, has proven to get anything off in the past