Really Disappointed!

I purchased this mascara for about $3, usually I love Wet n Wild but this product didn't work for me. I found that the very first time I used it, it made my lashes stick together in clumps. I had to take it off right away, and tried to reapply. I've tried using it a few more times since then just to make sure it wasn't me but it always seems to clump.

I also found that even though it is waterproof I end up with black smudges under my eyes throughout the day (I'm not rubbing them)

Overall not a mascara I would purchase again.