Really good for the price

I bought this eyeliner on sale, I believe it cost $4 and it's not much more expensive when sold at regular price. Initially when I did a thick line with it I noticed that half way through the day it would leave a mark on the upper crease of my lid which was awful. But with a thin line, the product will stay on really well. It won't smear and it is waterproof. I like that the black colour is very opaque. The brush is a little stiff but the pointed end makes for precise application.

The applicator in this stuff is awesome! I can get a great cat eye with it. It's water proof. But don't make a mistake when you're applying it because you will have ruined your makeup. You can't just wipe it off and try again.That said it does last a long time. I have fallen asleep with it on and still had perfect eyeliner in the morning! But I wouldn't suggest buying this if you don't have a good eye makeup remover on hand.