1 review

I submitted this review directly to the Sephora site, and I must submit it here because this product really let me down! I went into a Sephora and asked for the best liquid eyeliner and the two girls suggested this product by Make Up For Ever. I would definately not agree with...

1 review

This is by far the worst eyeliner that I have ever used! It came very highly recommended by the staff at Sephora because it is a new product bundle (the bundle is the eyeliner, as well as a Sephora eyeliner brush). The product is just terrible. I would consider myself a...

1 review

I have this in onyx, which is a nice, deep black. It smudges and blends really nicely. However, my eyelids sometimes get oily during the day, and this eyeliner will smudge right off.

1 review

You would expect an $18 eye pencil to work but this one doesn't really. It's difficult to get any colour from it, and forget about using it in the waterline! You will spend 5 minutes stabbing yourself in the eye only to realise there is no colour payoff. I think the pencil is...

2 reviews

Had a sample and it's just the same as drugstore black liners. Save some money and get the NYC one which is like 3$ in Canada, and even cheaper in USA.

1 review

I was trying to find a new eyeliner that can be applied with a brush. I used to use a loose powder liner however my eyelids started to get oily so it would end up in my crease instead of my eye line. I bought this one based on reviews but it barely lasted an hour before it...

1 review

There is nothing to rave about. It has a weird texture, I can rub it off super easily. The applicator and is nice and precise. The formula isn't great, it has a weird metallic sheen that makes my eyeliner appear wet, which isn't my deal.

1 review

Le produit sèche tellement vite que j'ai à peine eu le temps de le mettre sur ma paupière. Il faut tremper souvent le pinceau et si on l'oublie quelques minutes de trop, ça prend un gros nettoyage pour remettre le pinceau à neuf. La couleur est bonne, mais le produit a...

7 reviews

Love this liner. It lasts all day, goes on easy and is perfect for subtle or bold occasions. I find it really easy to use and I love the thin sponge tip rather than a brush. I also love that it doesn’t flake or crumble off. I wouldn’t say it’s waterproof but unless you...

1 review

I got this eye liner in a palette set. All the products I loved, except for this eyeliner. It's called Glossy Black. I find the pencil to be too soft and goes on quiet thick (it's very hard to control the thinnes/thickness of the line). It smudges pretty easy. If you're...

2 reviews

Overpriced for poor quality, I would not ever suggest buying this. It dries out and does not last at all. I compared to several other liquid eyeliners at Sephora and it is by far the easiest to smudge.

108 reviews

Definitely do not recommend. It does not glide on smoothly and it’s not worth the price. It’s a good concept but definitely a miss. Drugstore eyeliners are way better than this product and it’s less the price.

1 review

I received the Jonteblue Glittering Star Eyeliner in my monthly BoxyCharm subscription box and I wasn't over thrilled with this eyeliner. I found that the pencil was harder than other eyeliners I have been using for many years now. I wasn't overly impressed with having to...

2 reviews

I received this liner in my July Ipsy bag. I don't normally use pencil liners but tried this out anyway. It doesn't take much to get the full black pigmentation of this liner, which is awesome. Even though the colour goes on pretty dark it comes off very easily when touched so...

2 reviews

It's honestly one of go to liners. I love how easy it is to apply this. I usually go for bat-eye look so this really helps with that...no smudging and also very long lasting. Since its shaped like a pen it's also very precise and easy to apply. I def recommend this!

2 reviews

i tried the blue and purple ones on the back of my hand, i was looking for a felt tip waterproof liner to go in the waterline and for something that wouldnt smoog in the top crease ( asian eye). the coloured ones stayed great on the back of my hand, the black one i thought was...

6 reviews

So glad I recently bought this eyeliner as it is perfect. it glides on smooth and lasts all day. Very good quality if you are looking for a high quality eyeliner at a affordable price.

1 review

I like using Gel eyeliner because it is easily applicable. However I have oily eyelids which doesnt help keep my eyeliner till the end of the day.

1 review

The shade I had was Silk Taupe and it really is a gorgeous shade. Softens eyes beautifully and there is quite a selection of shades to choose from. I found it transferred easily onto my hooded lids and was quite a soft product. I began storing it in the fridge after it broke...

1 review

This eyeliner stays on for a very long time! It is definitely an all day product. The colour is very subtle.. so it's definitely not that crazy-bright make up that's impossible to pull off. It's wearable as just a subtle pop of colour. Especially behind mascara it becomes even...