We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eyeliner Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
201-220 of 902

L'Oréal Paris Infallible Never Fail Lacquer Liner

2 reviews

I’ve been buying this eye liner for a few years now, and I fell in love with how it works in defining my eyes with such precision.Easy to use,and gives the darkness and look I’m after. I’ve tried the eyeliner pencils,and other liquid eyeliners,but nothing has compared to...
Annabelle Cosmetics Kohl Eyeliner 115 Black Pearl

21 reviews

Smudge free best drugstore item in such a low price The colour of the pencil is really dark it stays for longer period of time I really like it its my go to pencil for every day use
Smashbox Cosmetics Always On Gel Liner - Fishnet

7 reviews

This liner will stay put all day long with no movement or transfer. My only complaint is that it can be hard to get a thin line. I have to sharpen the pencil after each eye, other wise I end up with one line thicker than the other. The good news is that it glides on like a...
e.l.f expert liquid liner

1 review

The liner is a good consistency, glides on smooth. For anybody that loves makeup but is on a budget, the prices at ELF are great. Plus they don't test on animals!
Urban decay eye liner pencil

3 reviews

My absolute favorite eyeliner! I cannot live without this! On a hot summer day I can trust this will not run or smudge on my face! Its absolutely worth the buy!
LASplash Art Ki Tekt Waterproof Slim Eyeliner

2 reviews

This eyeliner has an amazing fine and sturdy tip but unfortunately it does smear. After wearing it for awhile it had transferred to my lid. It goes on really well gliding across your skin leaving the perfect line so it’s such a shame that it transfers.
Covergirl get in line liquid liner

5 reviews

I was pleasantly surprised by this eyeliner. It is highly pigmented, lasts long and has a very fine tip. This is a great eyeliner if you're trying to achieve the perfect cat eye look.
limelight eyeliner

1 review

this eyeliner is amazing it’s so easy to apply it don’t smudge and stays on all day and night the “brush” isn’t a felt tip it’s like a bunch of tiny hairs
Maybeline New York Eye Studio Gel liner

12 reviews

I am just in love with this eyeliner. It’s extremely black and so long lasting . Love how it settles on my eyes . Smudge proof and the best eyeliner I ever used
VDL EXPERT DEEPMATT LIQUID LINER IN 901 BLACK

1 review

The rich pigment made me feel it's a long lasting beauty product. The thin sponge tip is hard to control. Also, this liner is not waterproof and smudge proof. Not quite what I want in an eyeliner. I received this product for free for test purposes.
Stellar Hyper Eyeliner Retractable Pencil

1 review

I bought this liner specifically for use in my waterline and for tightlining my eyes. I had read good things about it and the product description said that it is safe for use in the waterline, so I decided to give it a try. I am pleasently surprised by this STELLAR Hyper...
Essence extreme lasting eye pencil

3 reviews

Wicked stuff. I am constantly buying the peach colored stuff on the end because i use it under my eye when I wear eye shadow and eyeliner as it makes my eyes appear bigger. This stuff doesn't twist up and it doesn't sharper so what you see there is what you get. For the price it...
Wet 'n Wild black kohl eye liner

10 reviews

If you are looking for a black dark eyeliner to tightly line your waterline i mean sure this will get the job done but it does transfer through the day and won’t stay put too long
Doucce fine graphic pen

4 reviews

I received this in my Ipsy bag, I love black eyeliners. Although I'm not used to using liquid eyeliner pens, I normally prefer using pencils, I find them easier to work with. This pen I liked, I still gotta get the hang of it but I like that it didn't fade or smear and it dries...
Essence longlasting eye pencil

2 reviews

This product surprised me a lot and for the good. Because this is a pretty cheap product, compared to alternatives, with this one i had the same results of the expensive brands even better, because the color transfer much easier to the lid. Definitely i will buy more of this and...
Ciate London Fierce Flicks Precision Tip Liquid Liner Black

1 review

I received a full size Ciate Long Fierce Flicks Precision Tip Liquid Liner in Black in my monthly IPSY box. Once I tried it, it became my number one liquid liner! It dries instantly, and is so easy to use! It doesn't run, doesn't bother my eyes and comes off easily when washing...
Rimmel London Scandal'Eyes Waterproof Eyeliner

31 reviews

This has been my favorite eyeliner for years. It's not hard to out on, comes off fairly easy when you wash your face. It doesn't smudge much during the day and doesn't bother my eyes like other eyeliners have
essence Liquid Waterproof Eye Liner

29 reviews

This has got to be some of the best liquid eyeliner that I have ever used. Not only does this stuff stay on in the shower - bath and pool but this stuff stays on when you go to bed at night. This truly doesn't come off unless you use waterproof eye makeup remover. This even...
Colourpop Créme Gel eyeliner pencil

1 review

The formula is good, very smooth and pigmented! It is soft and easy to apply but it breaks easily and after three or four hours it transferred below my eye and it didn't seem true black to me more it was more like a dark gray. It is good but I've used better drugstore eyeliners.
Kajal Extreme Intense Eyeliner Pencil

1 review

I bought this eyeliner a while ago - Navy blue colour, and I really liked the eyeliner. IT is very smooth to put on and the colour itself is gorgeous. It can be worn with blue colour or with party wear clothes, and would look amazing at parties. I would highly recommend this!...