We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eyeliner Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
21-40 of 902

Marcelle Waterproof Eyeliner

15 reviews

I got this for myself at Christmas and wished I had bought it sooner. It is a waterline pencil that is safe and stays on all day and doesn’t run. It makes a big difference from what I usually use.
Wet N Wild Megaliner Liquid Eyeliner in Turquoise

6 reviews

I purchased this eyeliner in voltage blue which is an exquisite color that is extremely complimentary for brown eyes. It makes your eyes pop since it is formulated with high-definition pigment It is inexpensive as I believe I paid just under five dollars for this eyeliner. It...
Wet N Wild H20 Proof Liquid Eyeliner

10 reviews

This eyeliner is one that I always come back to, no matter what. It is very opaque and dark in colour and does not budge at all. It is easily usable for a winged eyeliner and lining my lash line. It easily comes off in the shower. I recommend it for sure!
Wet N Wild Mega Liner

16 reviews

I love these eyeliners as they are very good quality and provide long-lasting results similar to high end brands! The price point itself is incredible! They come in a number of shades as well. A great buy!
Max Factor Eye Pencil

4 reviews

I use this eye pencil in blue every day. I have blue eyes and it really makes my eyes look better.. makes them pop! I apply in the morning and there is no need to reapply. It’s a very effective eye pencil.
Wet n Wild H2O Proof Blending Eye Pencil

2 reviews

I guess I was expecting some sort or miracle product. It really isn't what I would call "H2O Proof". It lasts a decent amount of time compared to some others but it does still smudge when applied to the inner rim.
Maybelline New York Eye Studio Master Precise Liquid Liner

145 reviews

I've been recommended to use this eye liner by one of my friend. It was awesome for few days byt started geting dry later. The applicator is easy and effective to use but the tip is hard to move as it is kind of rigid. But it helped me giving perfect wing and lasts all day...
NYX Jumbo Pencil in Strawberry Milk

3 reviews

Although the jumbo eye pencils come in beautiful colours, they crease like crazy within a few hours of application, I've tried everything, from setting it with a powder to using a base, I have not tried my concealer as a base for it yet, so when I try that I'll get back...
Maybelline Unstoppable Eyeliner

35 reviews

I have tried many different eyeliners and this one seems to be the best! It doesn’t smudge, not oily, and lasts all day. I love that you don’t have to sharpen it and it’s sturdy enough to draw a confident line for eyelining. The value is unbelievable for how long it lasts...
Almay Propel/Repel Eyeliner

7 reviews

I like how it make my eyes bigger and pop
Lise Watier Black Stars Waterproof Eyeliner

5 reviews

I have big eyes, so I like to wear an eye liner 24/7. I have to say this is the best eye liner I have used so far. It's stays on for a long time. It is a bit pricey, but worth every penny. I am sticking to this brand.
Physicians Formula Eye Definer Felt-Tip Eye Marker

6 reviews

I got mine in "Warm Black" rather than "Ultra Black" and it wasn't a good choice. It looks like a watered down version of a normal black eyeliner. Brush dried up rather quickly as well.
Victoria's Secret  Very Sexy Eyeliner

1 review

The Very Sexy Eyeliner from Victoria's Secret is great. The liner has just the right consistency, so when I put it on...I only have to line my eyes once. A lot of eyeliners tend to not go on smoothly, and that's a big mess but, this one works perfectly! The colors are...
L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Noir Eyeliner

9 reviews

You REALLY have to work to get a good look with this, which made it so frustrating to use. It has a nice fine tip which in theory would be great for a "feline" cat eye, but there just isn't enough product that makes it to the tip, so the liner ends up coming out dry and patchy...
MAC Cosmetics Eye Kohl Eye Liner

17 reviews

This is a really great high-quality eyeliner that provides long lasting results. The only issue that I found is that it does smudge a bit but if that’s the look that you’re going for than this is great! Give it a try!
Chanel Stylo Yeux Waterproof Eyeliner

5 reviews

The best eye liner you can our purchase. You get what you pay for with this. Lasts all day long and doesn’t smudge at all which is very important for long days
Wet n Wild Eyeliner and Eyebrow Pencil

23 reviews

Why pay more than you have to?! I use this eyeliner to lightly fill in my eyebrows. I usually buy it at Dollarama and have never found a reason to spend more. I sharpen it to make it precise - but I usually use it dull to smudge in my sparse eyebrow areas.
COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner

14 reviews

This is a great budget buy! The eyeliner is often on sale, but even when it's not, it's a good price! The liner needs to be sharpened with a pencil liner, which I like because it gives it a sharp point. The formula is creamy and glides on the eyelid so nicely! Lost points...
L'Oreal HIP High Intensity Pigments Kohl Eyeliner

2 reviews

Soft and last long time, nice
Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner

3 reviews

I lkke the texture of this eyeliner. Light and glides on smoothly at the same time. Stays on for the day no problem. Easy to wash off once time comes. Good variety of colors.