We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eyeliner Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
121-140 of 902

Mary Kay Shadow And Line Eye Duo

2 reviews

These are very dry and drag on my eyelid to the point where it hurts, they're also not very pigmented.
NYC New York Color Eyeliner Duet Pencil

3 reviews

I bought this for around $2 CAD and it came in black and dark brown. It smudges a little but I love using the black for my eyeliner and brown for my eyebrows since I have dark hair. It's absolutely worth your money if you want two colours but only willing to pay around $1 for...
NYC New York Color Automatic Eyeliner Pencil

8 reviews

I have tried eyeliner after eyeliner and NYC HD automatic eyeliner is by far my favourite and all time go to. It lasts all day and helps me achieve the perfect look that I’m going for with the amazing smudge brush on the end. The twistable feature also saves me from having to...
Revlon Luxurious Color Eye Liner

1 review

THE BESTEST EYELINER EVER, LAST ALL DAY, SMUDGE PROOF,AND IT DOESNT HURT YOUR EYES WHEN YOU PUT IT ON. lIZ
Hard Candy Stroke of Gorgeous

9 reviews

Whenever I am on the go and dont have time to mess around with liquid liner, I use a eyeliner marker. They are less messy than a liquid, but I never get the darkness I like. This one did pretty well gliding over my eyeshadow and gave pretty good coverage that was easy to apply...
Annabelle Cosmetics Smudge Paint Eye Liner

5 reviews

I have almost every shade and I will never trade this for any others. The quality and the amount alone has kept me loyal since the beginning. Stays on all day, easy to use and I love the boldness of color.
Maybelline New York Master Drama Eyeliner

9 reviews

Cheap price Good packaging well detailed I like this alot my all time favorite drugstore eyeliner to go for.. doesn't smudge and stays on pretty well. A must try.
Physicians formula custom eye enhancing Gel CreamLiner

1 review

These eye liners are great! They come in stack able jars, with 3 colors in them. They are specific for your eye color. They come for blue, green, brown, and hazel eyes. I have the one for blue eyes. The top color is a dark, navy blue that brings out the blue in your eyes and...
e.l.f. Cosmetics Studio Cream Eye Liner

7 reviews

This eyeliner is by far one of the cheapest eyeliners out there. But there are other gel/cream eyeliners around this price point that perform better. (essence, wet n wild) That being said, this does do a pretty good job, it lasts a relatively long time, has pretty good...
Annabelle Cosmetics Liquid Eye Liner in Olive Chrome

1 review

I'm a big fan of Annabelle, for a lower end eye liner brands I've never had a bad experience. They offer nice solid colours that are easy to swipe across the eyelid and are mostly smudgeproof, while not WATERPROOF. I find that it stays on the eyelid most of the day...
Physicians Formula Gel Eyeliner

7 reviews

Holy Grail eyeliner? YES! I found this in walmart on a shopping trip for makeup and figured for 9 dollars for 3 eyeliners the price couldn't be beat! It took me close to a YEAR to finish the black liner and I'm still working on the other two colours, mostly using them on holiday...
Maybelline Drama Intense

1 review

Maybelline Drama Intense eyeliner-I have mixed feelings about this eyeliner. I didn’t know this eyeliner wasn’t retractable until after I bought it, so when I got it, I rolled the whole eyeliner up to see how much product it held. Big mistake. It didn’t roll down at all...
Milani LIQUIF EYE Metallic Eyeliner Pencil

8 reviews

Perfect hybrid of a liquid and pencil eyeliner! This product definitely stays put. However, I did notice that it smudges a bit around the outer edge of my eyes.Just have a small mirror ready for check ups!
Revlon ColorStay Liquid Eye Pen

24 reviews

Tu traces ta ligne du coin extérieur selon ton angle souhaité, tu relies au coin intérieur et tu colores à l'intérieur des lignes, un vrai jeu d'enfant.
Physician's Formula Gel CremeLiner

1 review

in all honesty, these eyeliners are really comparable to mac's fluidlines. they last all day long, no creasing/smudging or running off. they're exceptionally pigmented and dreamfully creamy (easy to work with). i have only one objection: they're very drying. if...
MAC Cosmetics Fluidline in Blacktrack

26 reviews

This is one of my everyday essentials in my makeup bag, I like a black smokey eye look and a defined eyeliner which does not irritate or smudge, this does just that, I love it on my eye, you can make the line as thin or as thick as you want.
Rimmel London GlamEyes Professional Liquid Liner

11 reviews

I would recommend this even though it is not my favourite brand , I know we don’t all have the same opinions... but my boyfriend buys me this brand a lot evens though I prefer Essie
avon ultra luxury eye-liner

5 reviews

I like Avon eyeliner pencil as it goes on smooth and easy. No pulling on the skin or pressing hard because it is much softer than some brands I have tried
L.A. Girl Mark My Eyes Black Liquid Eye Liner

3 reviews

The tip of the eyeliner makes application easy and smooth. The colour applies boldly to the eyelid and the colour is long lasting making for less smudging and less mess! Simply, a great product!
Prestige Liquid Eyeliner

2 reviews

This eyeliner is creamy and pigmented and it literally glides on my lids. The colour is dark and stands out. When I saw how creamy these eyeliners were and how easily they glided on I was like great, they're going to smudge everywhere. This eyeliner, when you apply it will NOT...