We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eyeliner Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
161-180 of 902

Forever 21 Love & Beauty Eye Felt

2 reviews

I have sensitive eye lids and this product made my lids dry and flakey. Price range good but the product itself didn't do me any good
COVERGIRL Extremely Gentle Softliner

1 review

Cover Girl Extremely Gentle Softliner is water-resistant, smudge-resistant, long wearing and safe for contact wearers. It is hard to find but worth it once you do. It goes on easily and stays on until you remove it with make-up remover. It is gentle on the eyes for those with...
essence Liquid Ink Eye Liner

7 reviews

I definitely recommend this as it gives off a very good eyeliner wing because the tip is super precise and extremely pigmented! What I love about this eyeliner pen is it’s very affordable and doesn’t require a lot to use!
Neve Eye Pencil in Pastel eye Caramel/Bronze

1 review

I received my Neve Eye Pencil in the caramel/bronze shade in my last months GlossyBox. The Neve web site is in Italian, but you can translate it to what ever language you like if you have a program on your computer to do so. The card that came in my GlossyBox says that the Neve...
Annabelle Cosmetics Eye Liner in Black

16 reviews

AWESOME PRODUCT!! I purchased this Kohl eyeliner pencil from Walmart a couple months ago for $3 and I love it! Since I have sensitive eyes, I love the fact that it is hypo-allergenic but I wish it were waterproof. This eyeliner has a creamy consistency and glides on easily. It...
COVERGIRL Brow & Eyemakers

6 reviews

Perfect colour for filling in my light eyebrows. Blends nicely with an eyebrow brush. The only thing that would make this product better is a dual end with its own eyebrow brush so i dont always have to search for mine. I buy multiples of these every time I restock. Price cannot...
COVERGIRL Duo Eyeliner Pencils

4 reviews

Only used black or jet black. Does the Job and last hours. Only eye liner I purchase. Price is reasonable. Will purchase again of course. Recommend this item
COVERGIRL Perfect Point Plus Eye Liner

3 reviews

BEST eyeliner ever! It goes on so smooth and lasts all day! I never have to reapply it or fix any smudges! I would recommend this eyeliner everyday all day!
NYX Slide On Glide On Waterproof Eyeliner

13 reviews

I use this on my water line and it is the only eyeliner I have found that actually stays put!! And believe me, I have tried every other liner out there. Thank you for making this product!
essence Liquid Waterproof Eye Liner

29 reviews

This has got to be some of the best liquid eyeliner that I have ever used. Not only does this stuff stay on in the shower - bath and pool but this stuff stays on when you go to bed at night. This truly doesn't come off unless you use waterproof eye makeup remover. This even...
essence Gel Eyeliner

30 reviews

Honestly it's around $5 for this and it gets the job done-as long as you have an eyelid primer on beforehand no complaints ! Pleasantly surprised it held up for hours glided on smoothly. It is a cheap brand but some of their stuff is pretty good would recommend checking it out !
Milani Color Play Felt Tip Pen

1 review

I love the Milani Color Play Felt Tip Pens for their precise lines however I don't like their wear. Milani claims these pens are waterproof but they came off easily with some rubbing. I would personally still buy them just because I haven't found a liquid eyeliner that create...
Physicians Formula 2-in-1 Lash Boosting Eyeliner Serum

27 reviews

I have used this eyeliner for years. Liquid felt too eyeliners always crack on me and look to harsh. This one looks so nice on my eyes and is waterproof. I have tried higher end eyeliners like the kvd and tarte but this one tops them all
Sue Devitt Eye Define Tanzania

1 review

Sue Devitt Eye Definer in Tanzania is amazing and makes BLue Eyes POP. Just a smudge of liner is all you need to have your eyes smolder without looking over done!
Chanel Ligne Extreme Liquid Eyeliner

1 review

This liquid eyeliner has a very deep, rich and bold black. The tip is very fine for precise lines and stays put the whole day. Good for every day use imo!
THEFACESHOP Make Me Star Eye Liner

1 review

This little waterproof gel eyeliner is a gem! The line comes in a range of colors and each color has a speck of sparkle in them. Currently loving the Bronze shade as it gives a depth to my eyes without the harsh look of a black eyeliner. The liner is very smooth and glides on to...
Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner

9 reviews

I find this eyeliner brush style easiest to apply. As long as you don't touch your eyes it won't come off for well over 24hours. I have woken up the second day looking pretty good (don't judge, I know I should remove my eye makeup at night). When it does come off with makeup...
Rimmel London Scandal'Eyes Gel Pot Waterproof Eyeliner

17 reviews

I definitely recommend as this eyeliner is really pigmented and I love the application as it comes on so easily without any hassles! This eyeliner is truly waterproof and doesn’t smudge or run!
MicaBeauty Gel Eyeliner

2 reviews

I am very thankful that I received this product in a monthly subscription. Otherwise, I would never pay such I price for this. I have to say though, it has an exceptional staying time, does not run, and - really - has to be the best eyeliner I have ever used.
Maybelline Expert Eyes Twin Brow & Eye Pencil

6 reviews

Love love love these eyeliner and eyebrow pencils! They go on silky and not chalky and the pencil blends in very well with your natural brows. I also love the cat eye look using this