I got this a few months ago, thinking it was a soft shimmery gray but the name is actually Black Pearl (115).
It is a bit different than the shade I was expecting, but still nice! It's kind of a charcoal shimmer I guess.
When I first tried this out I noticed it felt really dry compared to other eye liners I've used. Because of this, it doesn't seem to 'glide' on like other products either, but I can live with that.
I've tried smudging this to make a kind of smokey effect, but it doesn't work well. It comes off, but doesn't really move around, which is a good thing anyway if you don't want raccoon eyes halfway through your day/night.
For the price and the staying power this has, I would recommend it. But I don't think I will buy again, personally - I think I prefer something that feels softer.

I've been using it for years and loveeee this eye liner! It goes on very smoothly, and is really pigmented! It's well priced and lasts a long time, since it doesn't dry up or crumble when you sharpen it. Depending on your control you can get a smooth line, with one pass or can smudge it pretty easily, if you want a different look.

It does rub off pretty easily, which means you can be left raccoon eyes after a long day at work or a tear-jerker movie. However it is a great every day liner!!

To be honest this must be one I dislike. First reason it doesn't last it fades away quickly. Second it runs so it I have to take it off.. I highly recommend you try another eyeliner but if you don't believe me try it. No wonder its always on sale :)

This khol eyeliner did not agree with my eyes at all. I have asian eyes that fold in more, so it's hard to find eyeliners that won't smudge after a day's wear. However, this eyeliner smudged off after an hour or two and after a day of wearing it, disappeared. It left me pretty frustrated. I know my eyes have a lot to do with how well the liners stay on, but I've definitely tried better.

Personally I love this product there is a downside that I will get to. But these were on sale for around $3 and Annabelle had coupons on their site for $2 off so I stocked up on them. I love the quality of this eyeliner because it is very pigmented unless NYC and it seems to last for a while. And gives my eyes this special pop that I love.

Two downsides of this product is 1) the eyeliner does not have a plastic wrapper on the top which I emailed to let them know about. Because out of the 3 eyeliners I purchased 2 seemed to be used and it was not hygenic at all. Secondly I found this eyeliner to irritate my eyes. It left my eyes blurry and stung and kind of felt liek a billion eyelashes had fallen into it. I don't know if it is was only for me but I let my mom try it and she said the same.

That being said I still tolerate it because I love this product too much to even think about switching back to my other brands :)

I'm using this eyeliner at the moment, but it's not the best. I still can't find one that doesn't smudge throughout the day. It goes into the creases of your eye and smudges everywhere and it's not just because of the heat in the summer. I ve used it in the winter too and it just doesn't last for me. 10 mins. after putting it on it looks like it disappeared.

I love this eyeliner. I'm old school with my pencil liners, I don't like the twist out ones, I like the ones that you have to sharpen very so often. Once I switched to this eyeliner, I never went back to any others. It's great for daily use and lasts most of the day. It can usually use a quick re-apply if you plan on going out after work, but it lasts a good ten hours on a regular day.

I was able to find these on sale for $3 each, and I had $2 off coupons to apply to them, so they were a great price for me. Overall, the quality of Annabelle products are very good for the price that you pay. The texture of the kohl liners seem to depend on the color that you get. Some are definitely softer than others. Overall though, they do give a nice color payoff, and the color selection is very good. One thing that I have noticed though is that unless the color is set with powder, it seems to fade throughout the day.

This product was amazing. It goes on very smoothly, and shows up nicely. The best part is IT LASTS!! The colour stays bold all day :)

I am always looking for a great kohl eyeliner pencil and Annabelle's brand did not disappoint. This is an averaged sized pencil and it's tip is the perfect size to comfortably glide onto the lashline. It goes on so smoothly and does not tug at the delicate skin on the lid. I didn't even need to warm up the tip before using it for the first time, which is great. It sharpens easily and I haven't had any issues with the tip breaking off or anything like that.

I applied the Annabelle Kohl liner to both my top and bottom lash lines, as well as the waterline and it stayed put for hours without smudging. I did apply eyeshadow to set the eyeliner though.

As for the colors, I simply adore them. They have your basic neutrals and some fun colors that I just have to collect soon. I also like how the colors stand out and compliment the eyes. This did not irritate my eyes at all and it was a breeze to remove. It actually came off with one swipe of a cotton pad that had a few drops of eye makeup remover. I didn't need to rub my eyes to get it completely off.

The price is also decent and I usually wait for a sale, so I got mine for approximately $3.00. I'm really happy I purchased this.