I wasn't blown away by this eyeliner. I have it in "huntress green" and I love the colour, but I find it can be a little tricky to sharpen and apply because it is quite thick. It could be smoother and I find that I have to use a bit more pressure than I would like to apply it. I also find it gets kind of cakey and you have to be careful not to layer too much so that it doesn't crease.